search

distribworks / dkron

Dkron - Distributed, fault tolerant job scheduling system https://dkron.io
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
4.22k stars 375 forks source link

Documentation lacking / UI - Busy menu / Time zones #1530

Open fabltd opened 1 month ago

fabltd commented 1 month ago

The Documentation appears to be lacking any details of the following:

In the UI the busy menu shows jobs that are completed?

Second there appears to be no discussion around time zones. When creating a Job we can specify a timezone - example "timezone": "Europe/Berlin".

Thanks

fabltd commented 1 month ago

Any update on this. We were considering the pro licence but I think we need an alternative ?

yvanoers commented 1 month ago

Any update on this. We were considering the pro licence but I think we need an alternative ?

You seem to have things backwards. If you don't have a Pro license, you get community support without any guarantees on response times or anything. With a Pro license, conditions can be agreed upon.

Please note that I am in no way involved when it comes to Pro licenses, I am only part of the community.

In the UI the busy menu shows jobs that are completed?

I'm unsure, it's been a while for me. It used to be the case though that the execution history would keep only 100 previous executions, preventing it from hogging space.

Is this with or without DST applied?

Whether DST applies depends on the time and the timezone, not the application using it. Europe/Berlin has different offsets for SDT and DST, so the correct time is automagically applied.

What is the time zone reference?

I don't understand the question, can you elaborate?

fabltd commented 1 month ago

In my experience the way a company treats issues is relative to there commerical support. Why would I pay for a commerical licence when the solution is untested.

I'm unsure, it's been a while for me. It used to be the case though that the execution history would keep only 100 previous executions, preventing it from hogging space.

This should be inculded in the docs !

Is this with or without DST applied?

Whether DST applies depends on the time and the timezone, not the application using it. Europe/Berlin has different offsets for SDT and DST, so the correct time is automatigically applied.

So it will adapt. Say the event is set to be at 8 PM the day before SDT is applied will the even occour at 9 PM or will it revert to 8 PM DST.

We are looking at this for a scheduler for events so this is important. Some other tools we have looked at get this wrong.

What is the time zone reference?

I don't understand the question, can you elaborate?

Time zones are often calualted bases on the system timing being UTC. If the system time is not UTC ( time zone reference) then they can be off.

yvanoers commented 1 month ago

Say the event is set to be at 8 PM the day before SDT is applied will the even occour at 9 PM or will it revert to 8 PM DST.

Suppose a schedule of * 0 20 * * * that is set to Europe/Berlin. On Oct 26 2024, the job will run at 20:00 Berlin time, which is 18:00 UTC time. On Oct 27 2024, the job will run at 20:00 Berlin time, which is 19:00 UTC time.

Time zones are often calualted bases on the system timing being UTC. If the system time is not UTC ( time zone reference) then they can be off.

Dkron does not assume the system to be in any specific time zone. Schedules that have a time zone specified will run according to that time zone, regardless of the time zone the machine has. When no time zone is specified, Dkron schedules jobs in the machine's local time zone. See https://dkron.io/docs/usage/cron-spec#time-zones.

fabltd commented 1 month ago

Ok it seems the Time zone only works with cron specification. If any other method is used to specify the time this does not work?

Also why does a Job need an email address there appears to be no reference to if / when emails are sent?