search

dkim0419 / SoundRecorder

A simple sound recording app implementing Material Design
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.49k stars 807 forks source link

Clone found #67

Closed IzzySoft closed 7 years ago

IzzySoft commented 7 years ago

Just in case you're not aware of, please take a look here. Especially at the line stating the package name. Looks like it's a clone of your project, no credits given in its description. The clone is even available at the playstore – no credits there either.

gaul commented 7 years ago

Similar to #66.

frankyxcs commented 7 years ago

This author here has also cloned this app from another github responsitory :) dkim0419 only rewrote this app a bit..so what is wrong and what is right.i have found the original app here on github some days ago. you you can blame everyone

fbnrst commented 7 years ago

Where's the original one? Could you give a link @frankyxcs ? Not to blame, I'm just curious.

frankyxcs commented 7 years ago

Hi personally i hate it to blame anyone and i think everyone has to clean first this own door but if i see all the guys there blaming others ...:( This is only an easy recorder app nothing more.

This is the original app https://github.com/MohammadAG/Android-SoundRecorder

So guys be careful in the future with blaming others please ! :)

IzzySoft commented 7 years ago

@frankyxcs I do not blame anyone for copying – if I open-source my tools (which I do) I explicitly permit that or even invite to. It's rather the "not giving credits" I blame. And in the case I turned up, even the package name was kept unaltered, which points to a general carelessness.

So nothing about "forking" a project, that's all fine as long as credits are given. Even if the license doesn't explicitly state this, to me that's what decency calls for – rather than running around in borrowed plumes.

Instead of blaming anyone personally by contacting them, another fine idea would be to keep a list of "forks" and "pseudo-forks" – e.g. right on the main page (README.md). Along with the source of where the original project can be found, if one "forked" the project oneself :innocent:

frankyxcs commented 7 years ago

Hi OK peace together :) But as you can see even dkim ist not clean :) So we should forget about this and he should close this thread. But you are right. It would be always nicer from people to give credits or if they change, improve the code etc. to mention maybe the original author.

IzzySoft commented 7 years ago

No war declared :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

I was hoping for @dkim0419 to pick my hint, which would satisfy the issue both ways (up and down), and then close this issue. Maybe I'm just too idealistic, wanting to make the world a better place :innocent:

dkim0419 commented 7 years ago

yep, i did use that project to learn especially how to use sql in android (both implementing the db and displaying it in a list). i will credit him in the readme, my mistake for not doing that before.