Known defect: HRV Status Not Entering Ready Status - Multiple models

dliedke / Meditate

Totally free application developed by vtrifonov and compiled/enhanced for newer Garmin watch models by dliedke. Published in Garmin Connect IQ store at https://apps.garmin.com/en-US/apps/c5fc5ea5-7d12-4fb9-be9c-701663a39db7

MIT License

26 stars 2 forks source link

Known defect: HRV Status Not Entering Ready Status - Multiple models #13

Open spvandermark opened 1 month ago

spvandermark commented 1 month ago

When selecting a meditation session, HRV stuck in “Waiting HRV” even with after holding light button for 15s then turning on watch again and retrying the app. Worked fine until the latest Garmin update.

Forerunner 965 Software version 20.26

dliedke commented 1 month ago

Yes, same issue here, I already did a lot of fixes but the issue always come back

dliedke commented 1 month ago

I was testing here, try the following:

1) Open app, HRV will not be detected 2) Hit back button and reopen the app, HRV will be detected

But it is pretty random!

spvandermark commented 1 month ago

Tried your test and it did not work the first few times. Tried minutes later and it worked. Very random.

I think it's issues with the software update. Researched and there seems a lot of introduced issues with HR and one specific for HRV.

https://forums.garmin.com/sports-fitness/running-multisport/f/forerunner-265-series/385137/after-latest-software-hrv-and-sleep-tracking-have-gaps

spvandermark commented 1 month ago

The shutdown and restart is also randomly working.

dliedke commented 1 month ago

From: https://forums.garmin.com/sports-fitness/running-multisport/f/forerunner-965/377764/hrv-gaps-the-solution

What is clear:

It is not a hardware issue: lot of people have watches replaced (including me) and it is still happening.
If you restart, you have clean readings for a couple of weeks, then back to the same.
It is affecting several models (epix, fenix, forerunner)
Cannot be attributed to sleeping patterns, since this wasn't happening for most before.

HRV is based on beat-to-beat metric directly from the watch. If watch is not providing it, the Meditate will not detect HRV.

It is a pain indeed, used to be better. Now even respiration rate is no longer working as well, even when HRV is detected.

spvandermark commented 1 month ago

20.29 was pushed out today and I was hoping it was addressed. Not so much, still same issues.

dliedke commented 1 month ago

Hello, I tried a lot of different approaches to fix this and no luck. I will keep this issue open forever.

Sorry about that

spvandermark commented 1 month ago

I'll keep on the lookout for any updates you try. Feel free to reach out if you need something tested. Keep up the good work.

dliedke commented 2 weeks ago

Thanks, so far for me the only way to fix the issue with HRV detection is really soft reset the watch. But even so sometimes it doesn't work.