search

dns-violations / dnsflagday

DNS flag day
https://dnsflagday.net/
147 stars 40 forks source link

add reference to fujiwara draft and date issue. #140

Closed vixie closed 4 years ago

vixie commented 4 years ago

attempting to modernize.

jelu commented 4 years ago

I removed the comment is arbitary, and controversial, it feels like a personal view and I don't get it after reading the linked doc. The doc recommends a value between 1220 and 1400, and 1232 is between that.

vixie commented 4 years ago

Jerry Lundström wrote on 2019-11-17 23:57:

I removed the comment |is arbitary, and controversial|, it feels like a personal view and I don't get it after reading the linked doc.

the explaination for it being arbitrary is attached to another issue. i will find it and link it here.

it is vital that the dns operations community consider the basis for this number, and the impact of various choices.

The doc recommends a value between 1220 and 1400, and 1232 is between that. the doc recommends further discussion of the number on the mailing list.

-- P Vixie

jelu commented 4 years ago

@vixie

the doc recommends further discussion of the number on the mailing list.

I can't find any such text.

jelu commented 4 years ago

I'm merging this in the meanwhile, we can add more explanations/references once we get the link to them.