search

docker / roadmap

Welcome to the Public Roadmap for All Things Docker! We welcome your ideas.
https://github.com/orgs/docker/projects/51
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
1.74k stars 256 forks source link

[Docker Compose] V2 GA #256

Open stephanierifai opened 3 years ago

stephanierifai commented 3 years ago

Tell us about your request Move Docker Compose v2 from release candidate to generally available and make it the default version for all OS.

Which service(s) is this request for? Dev-tools

Tell us about the problem you're trying to solve. What are you trying to do, and why is it hard? Turning this option on by default in Docker Desktop users, will allows users can seamlessly move to Docker Compose V2 will help improve adoption, while still maintaining the flexibility to opt out.

Are you currently working around the issue? N/A

Additional context N/A

masatana commented 2 years ago

Hi,

Is this still "Almost There"? Are there any technical issue?

stephanierifai commented 2 years ago

Hi! Yes, still in almost there. We're going to time the GA with the next release of the CLI, which right now we don't have a definitive timeline for. We wanted to make sure there was an easy install path for Linux users before we called this GA. A bit more details here: https://docs.docker.com/compose/cli-command/#transitioning-to-ga-for-compose-v2 ! Let me know if that helps :)

tstibbs commented 2 years ago

Any news on this? Looks like there's been two cli releases since the comment above (20.10.13 and 20.10.14) so did the transition to GA happen or is there something else holding it up?

If it's still in progress, it would be useful to see the tickets that relate to that so it's clear what's outstanding. As it currently stands, it's very unclear just how GA-ready v2 is (so difficult to know whether to switch in an enterprise environment).

stephanierifai commented 2 years ago

Hi! We're very close to the announcement on GA (about a month or so), there are no technical barriers from using it in an enterprise environment. We had yet to call it generally available since prior to the 20.10.13 release it was not easily available to download on Linux, now that we have made it an optional plugin, we are working on transitioning our docs and guides to make v2 the default!

nemchik commented 2 years ago

The packages that have been made available have been very helpful! I can't wait to see a full inclusion into cli, and/or installation via https://github.com/docker/docker-install

stephanierifai commented 2 years ago

Hi all! Yesterday marked GA, check out the announcement here!

nemchik commented 2 years ago

Hi all! Yesterday marked GA, check out the announcement here!

This is great news!

Is there a specific version of compose v2 that is considered GA?

I ask because the latest version released on GitHub as of writing is 2.4.1 while the latest version available from the docker-ce repository is currently 2.3.3 (which has some issues that were fixed in 2.4.x such as https://github.com/docker/compose/commit/85a4d04096d130fb88d4344ffd95fdfb25cbcdc1 ). Per a previous comment it seems like there is work being done to get the repository updated more regularly.

Edit: There's actually some important fixes in https://github.com/docker/compose/commits/v2 that have not yet been released in a new version ( https://github.com/docker/compose/commit/625a48dcf712f52e1aae64cd664a97699a4fe5bf https://github.com/docker/compose/pull/9386/commits/9cfea28d589ca97a58d8c78d3f5f0be8118bcff2 https://github.com/docker/compose/pull/9386/commits/0da4543333cf01890024be29091d14acec7bf01a )

ndeloof commented 2 years ago

@nemchik G.A doesn't apply to a specific version of compose v2, we use this terminology to qualify software being considered stable (while, obviously, some bugs still can exist) and available on all supported platform, which is the case as docker-ce-repository now offers compose v2 for Linux as system packages. Those are not updated yet with latest release but will be soon. We are also working on making our packaging pipeline more flexible so we can keep version in sync without such delays.

nemchik commented 2 years ago

@nemchik G.A doesn't apply to a specific version of compose v2, we use this terminology to qualify software being considered stable (while, obviously, some bugs still can exist) and available on all supported platform, which is the case as docker-ce-repository now offers compose v2 for Linux as system packages. Those are not updated yet with latest release but will be soon. We are also working on making our packaging pipeline more flexible so we can keep version in sync without such delays.

Thanks for the follow up! I appreciate the explanation and all the work you've done!

johnthagen commented 2 years ago

@stephanierifai Now that GA is announced, will new Compose V2 Docker images be released?

This is the final blocker our company has to fully switching over to Compose V2.

stephanierifai commented 2 years ago

hi @johnthagen I think you saw, but we shipped it and now closed it! Thanks for the feedback :D