dodgingpixels / Optic

Public issue tracking for Optic - Photo Gallery [Android App]
15 stars 1 forks source link

Use right colors for app system iconography #17

Closed jahirfiquitiva closed 6 years ago

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

Material design has some guidelines for texts and icons colors in every theme.

I think using the right colors will make it look better than the current full-black icons in light theme (for example).

staber commented 7 years ago

Are you referring to the menu items or the bottom sheet, image actions?

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

@staber both

staber commented 7 years ago

weird... The menu items are all vector drawables, with Material fill colors, but the style/theme may be overlaying some tint. I'll check it again with the color picker like you mentioned.

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

@staber

Ok thanks. You could also consider tinting them programmatically to ensure they have the right colors.

Btw, I would like to mention that I like the app in general. Great work. Small details that I already mentioned.

Thanks

staber commented 7 years ago

fixed in v0.5.0

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

@staber

This isn't fixed yet. Right color should be #8a000000 (black 54% opacity) ... but seems like it is #de000000 (black 87% opacity)

staber commented 7 years ago

What are you using to evaluate transparency? The one's I've tried don't include it.

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

@staber

I must admit that I used my eyes only

But made this super quick picture on paint.net

Top-left is the color icons should be using. Top-right is the colors I thought they were using

And bottom is the actual color picked with Pipette

There's still a notable difference between the color they should be and the color that they use.

colors

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

Hey @staber this hasn't been fixed. Can you open the issue again?

staber commented 7 years ago

Material Dark background color is #303030 which is what I'm using for dark theme and the icon colors for light theme.

EDIT: I'm using Pixolor to inspect live.

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

@staber

Background colors are fine. Icons colors are not.

As I told you in a previous comments, guidelines clearly say the color for icons should be #8a000000 (black 54% opacity) which is way different than #303030

Also, you cannot use a color picker to check transparency, but in a picture I uploaded in a previous comment, you can see the differences.

staber commented 7 years ago

I just tested some icons at black 54% and they appear very light grey. Pixolor reads them as #737373. I'll try them like this myself until the next release and see how well they go with the app.

jahirfiquitiva commented 7 years ago

@staber

Ok, hope the right color make it to release

staber commented 6 years ago

fixed in v0.5.2

jahirfiquitiva commented 6 years ago

@staber Not completely fixed. Settings still show full black icons. Also the texts are full black if I'm not wrong :/