Fallout 4 GOTY Godrays Flickering and Texture Bugs

[mikhaelcool7]

Problem

Random blurry textures covering parts of the map and sometimes even hide doors. You can easily walk through them but they can sometimes cover up useful places or even items. Godrays flicker when set to low. Higher graphical quality was not tested as it is very demanding.

Software information

Fallout 4 GOTY

• 16:10 1280x800
• 40Hz 40FPS cap
• TAA
• Anisotropic Filtering 16
• Texture Quality Ultra
• Shadow Quality Medium
• Shadow Distance Medium
• Decal Quantity Medium
• Lighting Quality Medium
• Godrays Quality Low or Off to remove flickering
• Depth of Field Standard
• Ambient Occlusion SSAO
• SSR, Wetness, RO, MB, LF all on
• View Distance all sliders to 0
• Distant Object Detail Ultra
• Object Detail Fade Low

System information

• GPU: Steam Deck APU
• DXVK/Wine version: GE-Proton 7-37

[Blisto91]

When you say flickering you mean it can have lines like this that can move around as you move around like below screenshot?

Screenshot


Or do you mean the light itself themselves kinda shimmer/flicker when you look at them or the sun and move the mouse like the video?

Video

https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/47954800/195172830-18fb0b3f-1a99-4eac-b111-d117c900f59d.mp4

[mikhaelcool7]

Both

[Blisto91]

Rgr. For the texture issue does it happen in specific places or is it random

[mikhaelcool7]

I haven’t gone back to those places but I will have a look tomorrow after work

[Blisto91]

Made a trace of the light issue (for the devs) https://mega.nz/file/AxADFDZa#Nsv8_LNZdzYdIUo9Q-gDWYsOr1zR53LReWSerzd7Ldk

It is a bit annoying to reproduce since it seems like a race condition or something else random as it doesn't happen on every start. Same for when replaying the trace as i had to replay it like 10-15 times before it showed.

Edit: Although all of a sudden i reproducing it alot more easy in the trace for some reason and now it happens almost everytime. It also changes behavior from time to time so the two light things in my post above is actually the same issue.

[doitsujin]

Do we know if this is a regression? Does this only affect the GOTY edition or the regular game as well? The latter is not known to have this issue.

DXVK/Wine version: GE-Proton 7-37

Which DXVK build is that exactly?

[Blisto91]

The light issue from what i can see it is not a regression. In the trace i made i saw the issue also when i replayed with dxvk 1.7. I only have the base game and there it is a issue too. GE-Proton 7-37 is dxvk f8bd19f

From time to time it can be annoying to reproduce consistently. I will try to check it out on Windows too with dxvk and also on Nvidia.

The texture issue i don't know about

[mikhaelcool7]

Does this only affect the GOTY edition or the regular game as well?

They are both the same game unlike Fallout 3 and I don't think DLC has an impact. I am not using the 4K textures DLC

[mbriar]

Not sure if this really concludes anything, but i replayed the apitrace 100 times each with both RADV from git, RADV 22.1.7 and AMDVLK 2022.Q3.5 on a 6700XT, letting it snapshot a specific frame each run like so:

for i in $(seq -w 1 100)
do
    wine d3dretrace.exe --snapshot-prefix=/tmp/FO4/$i-run- --snapshot=4222611 --headless Fallout4.trace
done

and there were zero broken frames with AMDVLK or RADV from git, but with RADV 22.1.7 about 20/100 frames showed the broken lighting. All this was on dxvk f8bd19f210d32.

[K0bin]

No issues on Nvidia either.

Probably a good idea to open a Mesa issue then and ideally someone could bisect RADV.

[mbriar]

A bit annoying to bisect when you need to run it 100 times to be reasonably sure if the issue is there or not - would take a while even with headless apitrace, otherwise I'd have done it already. -- Sent with Tutanota, enjoy secure & ad-free emails.

12 Oct 2022, 17:40 by @.***:

Probably a good idea to open a Mesa issue then and ideally someone could bisect RADV.

— Reply to this email directly, > view it on GitHub https://github.com/doitsujin/dxvk/issues/2985#issuecomment-1276383968> , or > unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A3G6J6LLJ6VTFH6KKQCX2O3WC3LYDANCNFSM6AAAAAARCQSKQQ> . You are receiving this because you commented.> Message ID: > <doitsujin/dxvk/issues/2985/1276383968> @> github> .> com>

[Blisto91]

and there were zero broken frames with AMDVLK or RADV from git, but with RADV 22.1.7 about 20/100 frames showed the broken lighting.

Thx for the heads up. I tested with 22.1.7. I will retest with mesa git as you said. If the light issue isn't a thing anymore on mesa git then there's no need to bisect.

[Blisto91]

Can confirm mesa-git fixes the light issue. Nice find @mbriar So that should solve itself in a future driver update.

Should be able to focus on the geometry/texture issue instead.

[Blisto91]

@mikhaelcool7 Did you get to check if the texture issue only appears in certain places? 🙂

[mikhaelcool7]

@mikhaelcool7 Did you get to check if the texture issue only appears in certain places? 🙂

I was not able to replicate the texture issue while standing in the same place. Perhaps it depends on the time of day but I haven't encountered the issue since

[Blisto91]

Can you show the location of one of the screenshots above? Would like to do some testing :slightly_smiling_face: Or provide a save game.

[mikhaelcool7]

Save File: Exitsave0_8C236813_4D4337_Commonwealth_001341_20221015140955_11_2.zip

[Blisto91]

I've tried a few times to reproduce the issue on Deck with the save in that location, but haven't been able to.

[Blisto91]

@mikhaelcool7 Friendly ping. Have you still not seen this issue since?