search

donders-research-data-management / rdm-wiki

Technical documentation for RDM
http://donders-research-data-management.github.io/rdm-wiki
1 stars 2 forks source link

RDC identification number #15

Closed robertoostenveld closed 8 years ago

robertoostenveld commented 8 years ago

TBD: Do we require that the RDC identification number to corresponds to a closed collection?

robertoostenveld commented 8 years ago

It now says: "All publications of which the results depend on data are also represented in the repository as a RDC, and therefore every DSC is associated with a RDC. The DSC must be associated with this RDC by adding the RDC identification number as an attribute."

Say that you share data prior to finalizing a publication... or that you record data just for the purpose of sharing. In that case there is no closed RDC, or not even a RDC. So I think that this should not be a requirement.

In the statement in the text I believe the therefore to be logically flawed. All publications linked to the DSC are in the RDM, but there might be 0, 1 or more of them. Hence a DSC might be associated with a RDC.

I changed it into: "All publications of which the results depend on data are also represented in the repository as a RDC, and therefore a DSC can be associated with one or multiple RDC. The DSC must be associated with the corresponding RDCs."

robertoostenveld commented 8 years ago

mac011> git commit researcher.md [master 40c5b52] reolved https://github.com/Donders-Institute/donders-institute.github.io/issues/15 1 file changed, 2 insertions(+), 4 deletions(-)