Remove Fody and use MVVM Toolkit source generators

dotnet / ResXResourceManager

Manage localization of all ResX-Based resources in one central place.

MIT License

1.32k stars 217 forks source link

Remove Fody and use MVVM Toolkit source generators #600

Closed bdovaz closed 11 months ago

bdovaz commented 11 months ago

It is the most convenient (only attributes need to be set) and secure (AOT compatible) way to use this pattern today:

https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/dotnet/communitytoolkit/mvvm/generators/overview

tom-englert commented 11 months ago

INotifyProperyChanged is not the only usage of Fody, so much luck!

tom-englert commented 11 months ago

Also the MVVM generator only supports auto-properties, but not with some logic inside (e.g. forwarding)

bdovaz commented 11 months ago

Actually, I was taking a look and Fody is used in this project much more than I thought (Fody + other NuGet packages from third parties or yours)... I honestly don't like it because there is too much "magic" that you don't see/understand if you haven't done it yourself and it becomes complicated to contribute to the project.

But well, matter of taste, I close the issue because actually removing the Fody dependencies only for INotifyPropertyChanged, does not solve anything.