search

dpaukov / combinatoricslib

Combinatorial Objects Generators for Java 7+.
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
88 stars 15 forks source link

Need method to randomly sample SimpleCombination #6

Open dpaukov opened 10 years ago

dpaukov commented 10 years ago

From PeterVermont on December 21, 2012 18:00:55

I would email but don't know your email address.

I am the main developer for MDR - Multifactor Dimensionality Reduction which is a fairly simple classifier used in bioinformatics. See http://sourceforge.net/projects/mdr/ Normally, users do an exhaustive search over attribute combinations but we also have a random timed mode. Currently I make no effort from to prevent the random from testing the same combination more than once. I would like a tool that would allow me to get combinations without replacement. The issue is that it must be extremely efficient and fast -- it is not worthwhile to just maintain a list of tested combinations. It would be okay and perhaps even preferable if the progression were 'psuedo-random' in such a way that all attributes were tested fairly equally.

Another related, but harder problem, is using evolutionary algorithms to test combinations. I have found that this tends to test the same combinations many many times, since I already use elitism so I don't lose track of winners, this is a big waste of processing time. If I had a good way to know what has been sampled previously I could prevent waste -- this would also act as a form of 'novelty' seeking which has been shown in some evolutionary algorithm contexts to be helpful.

Thanks,

Peter Andrews Norich, Vermont USA

Original issue: http://code.google.com/p/combinatoricslib/issues/detail?id=6

dpaukov commented 10 years ago

From d.pau...@gmail.com on January 31, 2013 05:49:24

Labels: -Type-Defect Type-Enhancement

dpaukov commented 10 years ago

From ryan.gus...@gmail.com on March 14, 2014 09:39:44

You can randomly select which results from the Generator to return. The Generator is an Iterable, so you could wrap it and return a RandomIterator which randomly returns results from the underlying Iterator. Get as fancy as you want in the RandomIterator.

The weakness here is that you are still dependent upon the underlying sequence of the Generator, which is not necessarily random between runs. The early results are more probable than the later results.