dracor-org / dracor-schema

ODD and schemas for dracor.org files
https://dracor.org/doc/odd
5 stars 2 forks source link

Type-Values used for <name>, <persName>, ... #76

Open ingoboerner opened 3 weeks ago

ingoboerner commented 3 weeks ago

We allow for typing <name>, <persName> (especially of the authors, but also characters) and the like. In the legacy ODD we had a close list of type values allowed for <person>: Following the strategy of #67 the closed value list will be converted to "semi" which means we provide suggested values that are supported by the API and/or foreseen in the encoding guidelines.

It would be helpful if we had not only examples of the type of names but also definitions or descriptions of the values, @lehkost

Currently I have:

<valItem ident="variant">
                                        <gloss>Name variant</gloss>
                                        <desc>Alternative to the name of a person</desc>
                                    </valItem>

I am not sure about the difference of "pen" and "pseudo" Could you provide better definitions?

 <valItem ident="pen">
                                        <gloss>Pen Name</gloss>
                                        <desc>Pseudonym used by writers or authors</desc>
                                    </valItem>
<valItem ident="pseudo">
                                        <gloss>Pseudonym</gloss>
                                        <desc>Fictitious name used by a person, often an author or
                                            artist, to conceal their identity.</desc>
                                    </valItem>

I am also not too sure about "noble", you mean names like "Catherine II"? There are two other terms that might be of relevance here:

At some point it would also make sense to look into the type values used for various name like elements and define a global type list that can then be reused in the schema.

ingoboerner commented 3 weeks ago

What we also have is "patronym", but on a sub-element:

<valList mode="replace" type="semi">
                                    <valItem ident="patronym">
                                        <gloss>Patronym</gloss>
                                        <desc>Father-derived middle name. Used for example in in
                                            RusDraCor.</desc>
                                    </valItem>
                                </valList>
ingoboerner commented 3 weeks ago

See also https://github.com/dracor-org/dracor-api/issues/119 And did we have an issue on HunDraCor name things, like the ordering of the names?