search

dracutdevs / dracut

dracut the event driven initramfs infrastructure
https://github.com/dracutdevs/dracut/wiki
GNU General Public License v2.0
599 stars 400 forks source link

Dracut PXE/NFS boot hangs on starting network on Ubuntu 22.04 #2674

Open walid-omari opened 1 week ago

walid-omari commented 1 week ago

Describe the bug When trying to setup NFS boot for an Ubuntu 22.04 image that is created with debootstrap, generating an initrd with dracut makes the boot hang after root pivot and init phase at "Starting wait for network to be configured...". Disabling/masking systemd-network-generator.service and systemd-networkd-wait-online.service as well as omitting systemd module when building the initrd image allows the system to boot but then the network is left unmanaged and the interfaces that were renamed before init from eth0 to enp0s3 (for example) is then reverted to eth0 when the system is booted and running networkctl command shows all interfaces as unmanaged With initramfs-tools generate initrd image, the system boots normally and the interfaces are renamed properly from "eth0" to "enp0s3" and are managed by systemd as expected.

Distribution used ubuntu 22.04 LTS

Dracut version tested both version 051 (available in apt repos) and 058 (built from source)

Init system systemd

To Reproduce

  1. Setup PXE server (dnsmasq), grub...
  2. Create an ubuntu 22.04 image with debootstrap, chroot into the created image, install kernel (currently using 5.15.0-25-generic) and other packages you may need.
  3. install dracutand dracut-networkpackages and build an initrd image.
  4. export the image with nfs-kernel-server and boot a VM/machine with it.

Expected behavior I expect the system to boot properly like when using an initramfs-tools generated image.

Additional context I understand dracut is not usually used on Debian/ubuntu, but the reason I want to use dracut is its modularity and I find it to be less complicated than initramfs tools and specifically I want to do an overlay with the NFS exported image which is just a rootovl kernel parameter in dracut rather than a whole custom script with initramfs-tools that I was not able to make it work.

jozzsi commented 1 week ago

@walid-omari have you had a chance to try Ubuntu 24.04 or later ? I am assuming that your dracut version is very old on Ubuntu 22.04. I would also recommend reporting it to the Debian bug database if you not focusing on the latest version of Dracut (https://www.debian.org/Bugs/).

Note that rootovl is no longer supported in Ubuntu 24.04, neither it is supported here in this repository and your issue seems to be around that dracut module. Instead we use the overlayfs dracut module.

walid-omari commented 6 days ago

Dear @jozzsi , Thank you for your reply. I have not had the chance to try on Ubuntu 24.04 or later. as for the dracut version, I have tested both 051 and 058 as I mentioned before. I have also tested without the rootovl (directly mounting nfsroot and pivoting to it) and I got the same behavior so I doubt it had anything to do with that module. And I have not experienced this issue with the initramfs-tools that's why I thought the issue is related to dracut rather than Debian/Ubuntu itself.

I will however report it to the debian bug database and see what I can get. In the meantime, I appreciate any further input you may have.