search

dresden-elektronik / deconz-rest-plugin

deCONZ REST-API plugin to control ZigBee devices
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
1.9k stars 503 forks source link

LIDL Livarno Lux G10 Lamps #4822

Closed Guardempire closed 3 years ago

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

Describe the bug

  1. LIDL GU10 Light showing no Modellname (colortemperaturelight and extendedcolorlight versions)
  2. the extendedcolorlight is found as such but there is no way to change the color. color bar not shown. In Version 2.9 it was working but sometimes the lamp did not react so i tried a newer version which makes it worse

Steps to reproduce the behavior

If the problem is reproducable, list the steps here:

Search for new lamp, the lamp is recognised but rgb color can not be changed only the colortemperature

Screenshots

https://ibb.co/9wxds8B https://ibb.co/6JMNwPz https://ibb.co/88x333C

Environment

Mimiix commented 3 years ago

I am unsure if this is something in deConz.

Can you please check if you can change color using the rest api https://dresden-elektronik.github.io/deconz-rest-doc/getting_started/?

Is the (Color)light working in Openhab?

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

In openhab it was working, when the lamp was shown in the phoscon app with colors... But i know what you mean, its a phoscon/deconz bug, not a bug in the api, right?!

Mimiix commented 3 years ago

The API is deCONZ. Phoscon is, like OpenHAB, a user of the API.

If the functionality works with the rest api directly (as per my URL), the issue is within Phoscon/Openhab.

If it doesn't, the issue is within deCONZ.

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

Ok, i´ll try it out and write when i have more infos

LeoeLeoeL commented 3 years ago

I have those lamps. Phoscon reports: Vendor: LIDL Livarno Lux Model: HG06106A I confirm Phoscon doesn't show the RGB sliders.

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

So i tried some things:

The Phoscon Version where the RGB part works is 2.09.03. When the lamp is already connected the slider is also in the newest version 2.11.01 BUT when i delete the lamp and connect it like a new lamp the RGB slider is not there. Only the colortemperature slider.

I made some things with the api from your link. First time but i could manage to get some numbers... what i am not able to is to change the "colormode" from "ct" <- i think it stands for colortemperature to xy <-- that i found when RGB was "active"

perhabs someone got the "code" to change the colormode so i can try if its the working with this version

Thats the numbers when i am on Version 2.11.01 { "ctmax": 65279, "ctmin": 0, "etag": "555eb08e2b4cd7c68ae44e84fcf2234a", "hascolor": true, "lastannounced": null, "lastseen": "2021-04-28T15:07Z", "manufacturername": "LIDL Livarno Lux", "modelid": null, "name": "Extended color light 4", "state": { "alert": "none", "bri": 255, "colormode": "ct", "ct": 262, "on": true, "reachable": true, "xy": [ 0.7, 0.3 ] }, "swversion": null, "type": "Extended color light", "uniqueid": "58:8e:81:ff:fe:d2:6f:c6-01" }

acid115 commented 3 years ago

The same problem i have with the LIDL LED stripe HG06104A No colorchange with phoscon oder amazon alexa (but i think this is an other problem, because the led stripe does not support hue - maybe it is a config issue in deconz plugin) But colorchange through api (set x and y) is possible, and also through the old web interface Open Wireless Light Control (2016).

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

I changed the Firmware today to 266b0700 and the slider is back. It seams like it is working now.

acid115 commented 3 years ago

Just upgraded firmware to 26390500 (latest for conbee), but no change. Maybe they have changed something in latest firmware for conbee2... But i think there is a problem in phoscon....

Mimiix commented 3 years ago

The firmware of conbee/raspbee doesn't change anything on how lights behave. A reboot or incorrect cluster reading is probably the reason why it changed.

I've asked Manup to reply.

manup commented 3 years ago

I think the problem is that in the REST API output the light says it is an "Extended color light" but the hue/saturation and colorcapabilities values are somehow missing.

I can't tell yet if the plugin is not querying them properly or if the lights actually don't have these.

Can you please provide screenshots of the Color Control cluster after reading the attributes. Description on how to query the clusters can be found in https://github.com/dresden-elektronik/deconz-rest-plugin/wiki/Request-Device-Support

We need to look at attribute 0x400A:

image

And Hue / Saturation:

image

Note these are examples of the IKEA CWS light not related to LIDL Livarno.

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

The firmware of conbee/raspbee doesn't change anything on how lights behave. A reboot or incorrect cluster reading is probably the reason why it changed.

I've asked Manup to reply.

I have tried this more than once and it makes a difference.

manup commented 3 years ago

I found a LIDL Livanro RGB E27 HG06106C in my testing box which I think works the same as the GU10. The light doesn't expose colorcapabilities, we should set this to a fixed value for xy.

There are hue and saturation attributes, but commands to them bring an error 0xC3 or will be just ignored.

So all we have is xyvalues, the Phoscon App can work with these but is likely confused of the missing hue and saturation. I'll check how to fix this.

manup commented 3 years ago

Fixed now in the Phoscon App it should be available tomorrow in http://phoscon.de/pwabeta and in the local version in v2.11.3.

The color and saturation control for these lights is a bit clunky but that seems to be a limitation of the lights.

LeoeLeoeL commented 3 years ago

Is the brightess issue fixed too ?

LeoeLeoeL commented 3 years ago

Maybe interesting. The brightness issue is present to Hue Bridge too.

manup commented 3 years ago

What's the brightness issue? At least for the RGB E27 HG06106C light changing brightness works, but it looks like similar to the colors there are rather coarse offsets between brightness steps.

LeoeLeoeL commented 3 years ago

The fastest way to get this issue is: Turn on the light Put at minimum brightness Turn off the light Switch off by physical wall switch Wait for some minutes Switch on the wall switch Now you have a lamp with the brightness at minimum but the cluster 0008 (Level Control) 0x0000 (Current Level) reports 255.

manup commented 3 years ago

The fastest way to get this issue is: Turn on the light Put at minimum brightness Turn off the light Switch off by physical wall switch Wait for some minutes Switch on the wall switch Now you have a lamp with the brightness at minimum but the cluster 0008 (Level Control) 0x0000 (Current Level) reports 255.

Unfortunately this appears to be a bug in the lights firmware which needs to be fixed by LIDL. There is not much we can do as deCONZ and the REST API can only rely on the state which the lights report.

Can anybody confirm that the GU10 Livarno Lux color sliders work again with http://phoscon.de/pwabeta ?

LeoeLeoeL commented 3 years ago

Uhm, how I can tell you? I deleted one GU10 from HUE bridge and paired to Conbee II. Now sliders are shown using the official Phoscon too. But, a E14 "candle" paired already shows the issue. So, I deleted the bulb and then paired again. Now sliders are visible.

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

Some for me! The already connected GU10 was without color slider. I deleted it and paired it again, now the slider is there. I will use it some days an report if there is any issue.

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

Ok, new findings. After a while, the RGB lamp is no longer switched by the Openhab rule and just stays on, while the white ones (modelHG06492A) work normally. When I go into the Phoscon web interface I can switch the lamp BUT the colour slider has disappeared again. After switching once via Phoscon, Openhab also works again, but the colour slider stays disappeared.

acid115 commented 3 years ago

Same here with the led stripe. After deletion and repairing the led, the slider for color change appears and can control the color. In phoscon-beta AND in phoscon. But, after restarting the gateway, the slider disappears again. If i look on the json, the colorcapabilities also disappears...maybe it is not persistent?

{"ctmax":65279,"ctmin":0,"etag":"8b65efc89350ae844d0501506f19df25","hascolor":true,"lastannounced":null,"lastseen":"2021-05-13T07:38Z","manufacturername":"LIDL Livarno Lux","modelid":"HG06104A","name":"LEDBand","state":{"alert":"none","bri":59,"colormode":"ct","ct":464,"on":true,"reachable":true,"xy":[0.4557,0.5175]},"swversion":null,"type":"Extended color light","uniqueid":"84:2e:14:ff:fe:2c:44:f1-01"}

Mimiix commented 3 years ago

To be fair: I never had this issue with my Ledstrip. Not on current or older versions. I use it with HA and it seems fine. Not sure if this could be due to another version or so.

acid115 commented 3 years ago

Yes, because HA just set x and y value. I have thirdparty app on mY smartphone, with that i can change color and ct. But it is not possible with phoscon or with alexa...

LeoeLeoeL commented 3 years ago

You are lucky. In Alexa I switch on a lamp but it stays off and a plug goes on !!!!!!!

acid115 commented 3 years ago

Then alexa talks to another deviceID... Or you have two gateway with same ID range... Or you have another problem. I have to open a new issue, but no time at the moment... Since a couple of weeks i have the issue, that when a device got powerloss (plug it off or sth.) Deconz forget the device after 5-10min. After rescan the device appears again, but the name is removed And the device has a new ID. So it is possible, that alexa has another id for a light and a plug has got the id from light....

LeoeLeoeL commented 3 years ago

the strange thing is it's always a plug (never another lamp) to take the command of the lamp i wanted to switch on.

Guardempire commented 3 years ago

Since it doesn´t work properly i hooked up my hue bridge and connected the LIDL RGB lamp to it. Since then no proplems with it. So it looks like a deconz problem for me?! I didn't really want to use the HUE Bridge as I only want to use one gateway, so while that is a possibility at the moment, it shouldn't be the solution.

github-actions[bot] commented 3 years ago

As there has not been any response in 21 days, this issue has been automatically marked as stale. At OP: Please either close this issue or keep it active It will be closed in 7 days if no further activity occurs.

github-actions[bot] commented 3 years ago

As there has not been any response in 28 days, this issue will be closed. @ OP: If this issue is solved post what fixed it for you. If it is not solved, request to get this opened again.

oywino commented 2 years ago

@LeoeLeoeL With the two LED lamps that I have; LIDL GU10 Model HG07878A and model HG06492A this did not come out as you said. Cluster 0008 and attribute 0x0000 Current level show the number 8 when on minimum level and the value 254 on maximum light level. Controlling the color temperature seems impossible. It randomly changes in all directions when trying to change it. These bulbs offer no color control.