ZGP Friends of Hue reported twice

dof250 commented 1 year ago

Describe the bug

When pressing the buttons of a "Friends of Hue" (enocean, in my case a Senic Gira) multiple times, there are multiple responses send by deCONZ. So sometimes the switch reacts twice.

Steps to reproduce the behavior

Press the switch multiple times, but sometimes only 1 press will do.

Expected behavior

Trigger the press once.

Environment

Host system: ESXi
Running method: Ubuntu VM
Firmware version: 0x26780700
deCONZ version: 2.22.2 (but the issue appears in all the last versions.)
Device: ConBee 2
Do you use an USB extension cable: yes
Is there any other USB or serial devices connected to the host system? No

deCONZ Logs

Below is the ZGP log when the issue appears. You can see the frameCounter 6830 was already there, but its triggered again half a second later by the GPP proxy with the same frameCounter 6830 number.

(That GPP proxy 0x3D58 is a LWA004 Hue light, but it are different Hue lights that "repeat" the message)

10:26:09:528 ZGP srcId: 0x01729BE6 cmd: 0x13 frameCounter: 6829 10:26:09:529 ZGP button 3000 FOHSWITCH 10:26:09:648 ZGP srcId: 0x01729BE6 cmd: 0x17 frameCounter: 6830 10:26:09:649 ZGP button 3002 FOHSWITCH 10:26:10:066 ZGP srcId: 0x01729BE6 cmd: 0x13 frameCounter: 6831 10:26:10:067 ZGP button 3000 FOHSWITCH 10:26:10:183 ZGP via GPP proxy 0x3D58 for GPD srcId: 0x01729BE6 cmd: 0x17 frameCounter: 6830, GPD lqi: excellent, rssi: -74 10:26:10:183 ZGP button 3002 FOHSWITCH 10:26:10:230 ZGP srcId: 0x01729BE6 cmd: 0x17 frameCounter: 6832 10:26:10:231 ZGP button 3002 FOHSWITCH

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

As there has not been any response in 21 days, this issue has been automatically marked as stale. At OP: Please either close this issue or keep it active It will be closed in 7 days if no further activity occurs.

github-actions[bot] commented 1 year ago

As there has not been any response in 28 days, this issue will be closed. @ OP: If this issue is solved post what fixed it for you. If it is not solved, request to get this opened again.

kopierschnitte commented 9 months ago

This bug still exists for me. Almost every 2nd button press produces two events:

09:23:54:896 ZGP srcId: 0x01732B98 cmd: 0x12 frameCounter: 4962
09:23:54:896 ZGP button 4000 (null)
09:23:55:130 ZGP srcId: 0x01732B98 cmd: 0x16 frameCounter: 4963
09:23:55:130 ZGP button 4002 (null)
09:23:56:040 ZGP via GPP proxy 0x65EE for GPD srcId: 0x01732B98 cmd: 0x12 frameCounter: 4962, GPD lqi: moderate, rssi: -88
09:23:56:041 ZGP button 4000 (null)
09:23:56:150 ZGP via GPP proxy 0xFB09 for GPD srcId: 0x01732B98 cmd: 0x16 frameCounter: 4963, GPD lqi: excellent, rssi: -60
09:23:56:151 ZGP button 4002 (null)

I've noticed that in case it works as expected, the ZGP via GPP proxy entries are missing:

09:27:54:393 ZGP srcId: 0x01732B98 cmd: 0x13 frameCounter: 4964
09:27:54:394 ZGP button 3000 (null)
09:27:54:581 ZGP srcId: 0x01732B98 cmd: 0x17 frameCounter: 4965
09:27:54:582 ZGP button 3002 (null)

dresden-elektronik / deconz-rest-plugin