drivendataorg / concept-to-clinic

ALCF Concept to Clinic Challenge
https://concepttoclinic.drivendata.org/
MIT License
367 stars 146 forks source link

Document the Alex |Andre |Gilberto |Shize algorithm #26

Closed reubano closed 7 years ago

reubano commented 7 years ago

Overview

Participants in the Data Science Bowl produced several algorithms that we would like to incorporate. To help facilitate this effort, we also want to add documentation so that contributors can make an educated decision when selecting an algorithm to incorporate.

Expected Behavior

This documentation should enable people to:

Design doc reference: Detect and select

Algorithm info

key value
team Alex |Andre |Gilberto |Shize
rank 8
repo https://github.com/astoc/kaggle_dsb2017
trained models https://github.com/astoc/kaggle_dsb2017/tree/master/code/Andre/nodule_identifiers
converted branch
ML engine Keras
engine-version 1.2.2
ML backend Theano
backend-version
training method
architecture
algorithm
OS
OS version
Python version
CUDA version
cuDNN version
notes

Technical details

Acceptance criteria

NOTE: All PRs must follow the standard PR checklist.

tjvananne commented 7 years ago

I'm reading through this one right now. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like the competition target variable was to predict the probability of the patient having cancer as a whole as opposed to the probability of each individual nodule being cancerous?

It looks like most of these go through the same z-slice normalization, lung segmentation, and nodule detection/isolation steps. But then it's the final feature generation steps that might need to be refactored quite a bit to tackle the new problem statement of predicting the probability of each nodule being cancerous. Is that a fair statement?

A feature such as total_number_of_nodules (I made that up as an example) aggregated at the patient level might still be important at the nodule level, but it does seem to imply that the goal was slightly different.

reubano commented 7 years ago

Answer posted here.

lamby commented 7 years ago

@tjvananne Did @reubano's link answer your question? :)

WGierke commented 7 years ago

@lamby same here - is something preventing this issue from getting closed? :)