drowe67 / freedv-gui

GUI Application for FreeDV – open source digital voice for HF radio
https://freedv.org/
GNU Lesser General Public License v2.1
193 stars 49 forks source link

[Feature Request] Display friendly name for audio devices when using PulseAudio/pipewire #739

Open tmiw opened 1 month ago

tmiw commented 1 month ago

Contact Details

tmiw

Feature for this project

Currently, when FreeDV is compiled with PulseAudio support (the default), it displays the internal PulseAudio names for each audio device on the system (i.e. alsa_output.xxx). Other applications (such as pavucontrol) as well as FreeDV with PortAudio show a friendlier name (i.e. "Monitor of USB Audio Device"). FreeDV should show this friendly name when using PulseAudio too.

VHF/UHF

No

Deprecated features

No

Non-standard compiler

No

Non-standard compiler

No

Implementation assistance

TBD -- need to determine whether there's demand for this feature first.

Support assistance

TBD -- need to determine whether there's demand for this feature first.

Tyrbiter commented 1 month ago

I think this is a sensible change, however it would be useful to allow access to the ALSA name via something like a tooltip for cross-checking purposes. Some other tools will only display the ALSA names.

I don't know if the pipewire roadmap intends any of the device naming to change, it would be a good idea to try to find out.

tmiw commented 1 month ago

I think this is a sensible change, however it would be useful to allow access to the ALSA name via something like a tooltip for cross-checking purposes. Some other tools will only display the ALSA names.

I don't know if the pipewire roadmap intends any of the device naming to change, it would be a good idea to try to find out.

Out of curiosity, what other tools only show the ALSA names? Has that caused usability problems for those?

Tyrbiter commented 4 weeks ago

I looked to see if I could find what I expected but it seems that even the older sound tools appear to use the friendlier pulseaudio names now. If I find anything else I will update this FR.

I reckon it would be useful to have tooltip access to the old ALSA names as I'm sure that some of the /dev tree has these names embedded in the output of some commands.