search

drphilmarshall / Ideas-for-Citizen-Science-in-Astronomy

Ideas for Citizen Science in Astronomy
3 stars 7 forks source link

Check ARAA galleys #145

Closed drphilmarshall closed 9 years ago

drphilmarshall commented 9 years ago

After first committing and pushing them!

chrislintott commented 9 years ago

My comments :

  1. 2.1 - Keep (ISON) after C/2012 S1 to fit with rest of the comet names.
  2. 2.1 - Can we update the mention of Siding Spring with Mars (provided worldwide...)
  3. 2.3 - Something gone wrong with the edit - suggest '...between 2010 and 2012; their light curves have been used to determine...'
  4. 2.5 - not 'the ability to find charts' but 'produces finding charts'
  5. 2.9 - Lose colon ahead of 'For example, ecological'
  6. 2.9 - Was just Geert
  7. 3.1 - Suggested text :

Classification of data sets is not a new problem in astrophysics, and a variety of projects have attempted to allow volunteers to make significant contribution to the task. In this section, we review the most prominent of such projects.

  1. 3.1.1. - BOSSA : Berkeley Open System for Skill Aggregation
  2. 3.1.2 - Not happy with 'was conducted by Willett et al'. Suggest 'is included in'
  3. 3.1.3 Should the title mention Moon Mappers not Moon Watch?
  4. 3.2 It's Simpson et al a. throughout this section
  5. 3.2 IBCC : independent Bayesian classifier combination
  6. Update SpaceWarps references! (Also in page 6.2)
  7. 4.1 This section is Simpson et al.b
  8. Holincheck et al : Probably should be Shamir, Holincheck & Wallin, Astronomy & Computing Volume 2, August 2013, Pages 67–73
  9. Change citation to Kaggle competition: Should be Diedelman, Willett & Dambre, 2015MNRAS.450.1441D
  10. Radio Galaxy Zoo paper nearly published...no references yet
  11. 8.2 Include (LOFAR) as well as expanded version.
  12. Acknowledgements : Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, Arts and Humanities Research Council.
drphilmarshall commented 9 years ago

Thanks Chris - closing this, and sending our notes to Roselyn!