search

dualB / Melody

Melody offers a simple an powerful music text notation called MELO.
MIT License
13 stars 2 forks source link

stm32f4 stm32f7 wont boot #5

Open bm16ton opened 2 years ago

bm16ton commented 2 years ago

For sum reason (and im new to coding so please forgive me if i use incorrect names/words) on my stm3f4/7 boards f413 f401 f411 f767 etc If I load the example Melody with tone then my stm boards will not boot, they all make it as far as dmesg showing new fs usb device and thats where they die, and I have to force a boot into bootloader to reprogram them. The Melody from serial works great on all of them. After deleting things till the stm's would boot I realized it was the call Melody char that breaks the boards but melody string works great! Ive tried this on arduino version 1.8.9 to 1.8.19 and on 2 x86_64 pc's and 2 arm64 pc's and with 2 different versions of the stm32-arduino package, and of course setting different pins. I dont think your lib is to fault my assumption is this has brought to light some poorly written stm32 implementation of sum arduino lib, I assume based of the example name the tone lib is used wonder if stm's is hurting? Anyone else have this issue? Again thank you for your work amazing lib!

dualB commented 2 years ago

Thank you for your feedback! If you could share a simple code example that makes an stm board crash everytime, it will help me to investigate a little bit inside my library, just to be sure. I didn't test my library on a lot of platforms...

bm16ton commented 2 years ago

Simple the melody with tone example unmodified will do it. (But not the melody serial that works fine) but its any line that starts with the word "melody" followed by the song name "bach blah" delete all those and it boots fine. Also replacing the char with a string version works fine. In the header i belive melody is listed a couple times like melody::melody char and.melody::melody string (thats from memory but basic words are correct) its any calls to the melody::melody char that bring it down....at least thats what i think the melody with tone example uses and the melody with serial uses melody string function? Which is why it works. Grain of salt im.new to a lot of this lol. If i was unclear i can goto pc and copy and paiste one of the offending lines. That would probly make more sense then me. Give me.just a quick min ;)

On Sat, 9 Apr 2022, 21:02 Claude Bouchard, @.***> wrote:

Thank you for your feedback! If you could share a simple code example that makes an stm board crash everytime, it will help me to investigate a little bit inside my library, just to be sure. I didn't test my library on a lot of platforms...

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/dualB/Melody/issues/5#issuecomment-1094151184, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADAWMPYJ7NSHZMBISF6WKZTVEISB7ANCNFSM5S77BBOA . You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

bm16ton commented 1 year ago

this is one of the lines (any that declaire a song)

Melody scaleLouder("c>>> d>> e>f g< a<< b<<< c*<<<<", 240);

and asecond one just in case

Melody mozartNachtmusik("g<<r-d- | g<< r-d-(g<dg<b)-d<r | c<<r-a-c<<r-a- |(c<af#<a)-d<r | (gr)- g. (bag | (gag)/3:1 f#)- f#. (acf# | ag)- g. (bag | (gag)/3:1 f#)- f#. (acf#)- | ((grgr)-- (gf#ef#)--)>> ((grgr)-- (baga)--)> | (brbr)-- (dcbc)-- d< r | ((de)+ | (d-c.)-c (c-b.)- b | (( b-a.)- a (gf#ef# | (grarbr)>)- r )_)> ", 140);

kinda surprised its able to stop the stms from booting so quickly. Im interested in what exactly is the problem but afraid I dont currently have the skills to figure it out.

On Sat, Apr 9, 2022 at 9:26 PM benjamin maddocks @.***> wrote:

Simple the melody with tone example unmodified will do it. (But not the melody serial that works fine) but its any line that starts with the word "melody" followed by the song name "bach blah" delete all those and it boots fine. Also replacing the char with a string version works fine. In the header i belive melody is listed a couple times like melody::melody char and.melody::melody string (thats from memory but basic words are correct) its any calls to the melody::melody char that bring it down....at least thats what i think the melody with tone example uses and the melody with serial uses melody string function? Which is why it works. Grain of salt im.new to a lot of this lol. If i was unclear i can goto pc and copy and paiste one of the offending lines. That would probly make more sense then me. Give me.just a quick min ;)

On Sat, 9 Apr 2022, 21:02 Claude Bouchard, @.***> wrote:

Thank you for your feedback! If you could share a simple code example that makes an stm board crash everytime, it will help me to investigate a little bit inside my library, just to be sure. I didn't test my library on a lot of platforms...

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/dualB/Melody/issues/5#issuecomment-1094151184, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADAWMPYJ7NSHZMBISF6WKZTVEISB7ANCNFSM5S77BBOA . You are receiving this because you authored the thread.Message ID: @.***>

dualB commented 1 year ago

Hello! First, there is a new version since june (v1.2.0) maybe it will fix issues with string/*char. Also, maybe it is a memory issue, because really long melody is too much to put in memory.