Awning : open/close reversed

hoefs commented 3 years ago

Thank you for your feedback. I just deploy a new version, it should fix both issues. Can you check and confirm me.

Thanks

Yes!!! Seems to be fixed now! Thanks for your effort!!!!! Much appreciated

Originally posted by @hoefs in https://github.com/dubocr/homebridge-tahoma/issues/234#issuecomment-770353151

After updating to homebridge-tahoma v2.1.3 my awning shows correct status (closed = closed and open=open). However when requesting to close it opens, and when request to open, it closes. This was not the case with the latest 0.x version.

github-actions[bot] commented 3 years ago

Thank you for using Homebridge TaHoma plugin.

Please follow these step to obtain better support :

Execute failling operations from official app (TaHoma/Cozytouch/etc.) then execute same operation from Homekit
Report your config by browsing https://dev.duboc.pro/tahoma
Search issues with title corresponding to your device widget name (see picture below). If no opened issue, rename your issue with this widget name.
Provide your bridge last 4 digits (number visible as SETUP-XXXX-XXXX-XXXX at step 2.)

Thank you.

dubocr commented 3 years ago

Hi,

Effectively in case of stateless awning there were a mistake. If you are in this case (stateless Anwing), latest release 2.1.4 should solve. If not, please follow previous comment procedure to let me investigate.

Thanks.

hoefs commented 3 years ago

Hi,

Effectively in case of stateless awning there were a mistake. If you are in this case (stateless Anwing), latest release 2.1.4 should solve. If not, please follow previous comment procedure to let me investigate.

Thanks.

Hi Romain, My info: SETUP-0803-2123-6951

You had fixed this type of awning with the last plug-in on 0.x. Will test tomorrow with the 2.1.4.

dubocr commented 3 years ago

Update from @hoefs :

1)

Connexoon app works correct = opening is opening / closing is closing
Homekit shows the correct open/close status. But the movement closing/opening is reversed. As you can see in point 3 - I have to request 10% closed to get 10% open, but the end state after the request changes to 10% open. 2) done 3) Awning > PositionableHorizontalAwning Devices click on a device to display current states Zonnewering

States Zonnewering io://0803-2123-6951/4100875 core:DeploymentState 10 core:DiscreteRSSILevelState (good,low,normal,verylow) normal core:Memorized1PositionState 66 core:MovingState (false,true) core:NameState SUNEA io core:OpenClosedState (closed,open) open core:PriorityLockTimerState 0 core:RSSILevelState 46 core:SecuredPositionState core:StatusState (available,unavailable) available core:TargetClosureState 10 io:PriorityLockLevelState (comfortLevel1,comfortLevel2,comfortLevel3,comfortLevel4,environmentProtection,humanProtection,userLevel1,userLevel2) io:PriorityLockOriginatorState (LSC,SAAC,SFC,UPS,externalGateway,localUser,myself,rain,security,temperature,timer,user,wind)

4) SETUP-0803-2123-6951

dubocr commented 3 years ago

@hoefs as I now understend you don't have stateless awning can you : Send an "open" command from Connexxoon, then give me from https://dev.duboc.pro/tahoma :

Latest command (in History) (eg: Zonnewering - setDeployment[0] - COMPLETED)
core:DeploymentState at the end of movement
core:TargetClosureState at the end of movement

Do the same for "close".

Thanks

hoefs commented 3 years ago

@hoefs as I now understend you don't have stateless awning can you : Send an "open" command from Connexxoon, then give me from https://dev.duboc.pro/tahoma :

Latest command (in History) (eg: Zonnewering - setDeployment[0] - COMPLETED)

core:DeploymentState at the end of movement

core:TargetClosureState at the end of movement

Do the same for "close".

Thanks

State was closed in homekit. Tapped it to open, only get spinner in the homekit screen. Nothing happens...

This is homebridge:

[3/23/2021, 1:58:49 PM] [Connexoon] [Zonnewering] setClosure[100]
[3/23/2021, 1:58:49 PM] [Connexoon] undefined
[3/23/2021, 1:58:49 PM] [Connexoon] undefined
[3/23/2021, 1:58:49 PM] [Connexoon] [Zonnewering] setClosure Error undefined undefined (undefined)
[3/23/2021, 2:00:53 PM] [Connexoon] Event Polling - Error with listener 5dc1234a-ac10-3e01-0169-e7622ac63de6
[3/23/2021, 2:00:53 PM] [Connexoon] Error undefined undefined (undefined)

Your server gives a ERROR 500

hoefs commented 3 years ago

@hoefs as I now understend you don't have stateless awning can you : Send an "open" command from Connexxoon, then give me from https://dev.duboc.pro/tahoma :

Latest command (in History) (eg: Zonnewering - setDeployment[0] - COMPLETED)

core:DeploymentState at the end of movement

core:TargetClosureState at the end of movement

Do the same for "close".

Thanks

seems 2.1.6 fixed it... have you changed something?

dubocr commented 3 years ago

v2.1.6 now use "deployment", could you try to update then tell me what's ok or not. Can you also said me what is "Open at 10%" with a screenshot of the homekit widget.

Your server gives a ERROR 500 : do you mean my server https://dev.duboc.pro/tahoma ? How ?

hoefs commented 3 years ago

v2.1.6 now use "deployment", could you try to update then tell me what's ok or not. Can you also said me what is "Open at 10%" with a screenshot of the homekit widget.

Your server gives a ERROR 500 : do you mean my server https://dev.duboc.pro/tahoma ? How ?

Your server seemed to be unreachable for some time, but is works now.

I requested in homekit to open 15% = correct: [3/23/2021, 3:07:10 PM] [Connexoon] [Zonnewering] setDeployment[15]

Zonnewering - setDeployment - HomeKit (23/03/2021 15:07:10) COMPLETED
Zonnewering - setDeployment[15] - COMPLETED

States Zonnewering io://0803-2123-6951/4100875
core:DeploymentState 15
core:TargetClosureState 15

I just push it again in homekit (to close) = correct: [3/23/2021, 3:09:39 PM] [Connexoon] [Zonnewering] setDeployment[0]

Zonnewering - setDeployment - HomeKit (23/03/2021 15:09:40) COMPLETED
Zonnewering - setDeployment[0] - COMPLETED

States Zonnewering io://0803-2123-6951/4100875
core:DeploymentState 0
core:TargetClosureState 0

Push it again in homekit (to completely open) - correct: [3/23/2021, 3:11:33 PM] [Connexoon] [Zonnewering] setDeployment[100]

Zonnewering - setDeployment - HomeKit (23/03/2021 15:11:34) COMPLETED
Zonnewering - setDeployment[100] - COMPLETED

States Zonnewering io://0803-2123-6951/4100875
core:DeploymentState 100
core:TargetClosureState 100

Seems to be working fine now... Thanks again!!!!

dubocr commented 3 years ago

Great,

I hope your device is not "specific". Can you confirm me you have no "reverse": true anymore in your plugin config ?

Will wait for feedback from issue #206 regarding other kind of Awning.

hoefs commented 3 years ago

Great,

I hope your device is not "specific". Can you confirm me you have no "reverse": true anymore in your plugin config ?

Will wait for feedback from issue #206 regarding other kind of Awning.

I think 206 was for the same issue.

I dont have any reverse. Never had:

        {
            "name": "Connexoon",
            "service": "connexoon",
            "user": "xxxx@gmail.com",
            "password": "xxxxxxxx",
            "platform": "Tahoma"
        },

Seems to be working fine again (as it did before the 2.x.x upgrade)

dubocr / homebridge-tahoma

Awning : open/close reversed #259