e-senturk
commented
3 years ago First, let me clarify that. On my side, AppleALC works very well because our speaker is different than yours. G531GT and GD have the same speakers but GU and higher have better speaker configuration. Second, patching APPLEHDA is not a better solution. It's the same solution as AppleALC. AppleALC collects these patches for various devices and patches AppleHDA externally. Even if you patch AppleHDA it will not worth it because you need to patch it on every os update and you have to modify system files and it ruins stability on OSX. Third, I can't patch your device because I don't have your device. I can't do it from a distance because there is a lot of trial and error phases, basically, there is no deep dive into the problem because for GT or GD devices there isn't any problem. Last, if you want a real solution you can patch it for yourself and send a pull request to the AppleALC branch. Then devs are probably will add it into the next versions.
trankimlonghai
Hi, I wonder if you acknowledged of this kind of patching appleHDA for codec
(Ex: https://www.olarila.com/topic/1817-how-to-patch-applehda/) => This guide will show us how to patch codec for our own machine running Hackintosh (AppleALC kext) and no need to use layout-id, I suppose.
Because I think this is the way the sound from speakers of Rog Strix G series should work properly!
You remember I ever told you I have had my laptop warranted to replace speakers because it's destroyed due to maximum volume on Hackintosh causes noise/echo/popping sound (I don't know how to describe this) but in Windows maximum volume cause no issue and speakers sound very smooth and great.
Let me know if you want to deep dive in to solve problem with sound on these rog strix G series with patching AppleHDA codec. I will send you codec dump of my G531GU when you have free time to investigate and finalize the EFI OC for these G531GT/GU/GD rog strix G. Thanks!