search

eXtensibleCatalog / Metadata-Services-Toolkit

Tools for processing and aggregating metadata
Other
6 stars 3 forks source link

marctoxctransformation ListMetadataFormats - no results #680

Closed patrickzurek closed 8 years ago

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA issue created by: banderson Originally opened: 2011-05-26 06:08 PM

Issue body: (nt)

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: banderson JIRA Timestamp: 2011-05-26 06:08 PM

Comment body:

Delis’ marctoxctransformation ListMetadataFormat command was returning no formats and thus drupal couldn't harvest:

wget -O- 'http://xc-demo.carli.illinois.edu:8080/MetadataServicesToolkit/st/marctoxctransformation/oaiRepository?verb=ListMetadataFormats'

here’s the issue

$ mysql -t -u root -D MetadataServicesToolkit -e "select
* from services_to_output_formats;"
+-----------------------------+------------+-----------+
| service_to_output_format_id | service_id | format_id |
+-----------------------------+------------+-----------+
| 85656 | 1 | 2 |
| 85657 | 1 | 1 |
+-----------------------------+------------+-----------+


not sure what the root of the problem was, though.


Delis said it used to work, but the only thing he change was:
listmetadataformats *used to* work. the only thing I did to the MST was what I've mentioned before about adding a set to an already performed process (marctoxctransformation), then later "undoing it" (by clearing it out).

 

I can't imagine there's a connection here, but we should verify it.

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: banderson JIRA Timestamp: 2011-05-26 07:39 PM

Comment body:

kysushu has also reported this bug.

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: jbrand JIRA Timestamp: 2011-10-04 05:14 PM

Comment body:

I can try to reproduce steps listed by Chris, but if that doesn't reproduce the problem, may have to but some debugging code in as an interim step.

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: rcook JIRA Timestamp: 2011-10-04 05:17 PM

Comment body:

I would also ping Peter on this incase he can add anything. The following issue came in on the Drupal Toolkit issue list.

Issue status update for http://drupal.org/node/1298500 Post a follow up: http://drupal.org/comment/reply/1298500#comment-form

Project: The eXtensible Catalog (XC) Drupal Toolkit Version: 6.x-1.1-beta4 Component: Code Category: bug report Priority: normal Assigned to: Anonymous Status: active Updated by: klmonnot

It wants me to select a format but there are not formats to pick.

klmonnot

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: pkiraly JIRA Timestamp: 2011-10-05 07:57 AM

Comment body:

The problem of klmonnot (Kathy Monnot, Web Developer of ServerLogic Corporation http://www.serverLogic.com) was caused that the Drupal installation profile pointed to another (old) MST demo, which has different URL, and which is not working right now. I updated the profile, and answered to Kathy in the drupal.org issue queue (http://drupal.org/node/1181574#comment-5076464).

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: jbrand JIRA Timestamp: 2011-11-15 02:35 PM

Comment body:

I asked Kyushu for more information - their reply:

I would like to pass information from Takashi although there includes some ambiguous things.

1) Have you seen this problem?

Yes, we have.

2) If so, were you using the proper URL? (It changed from MetadataServicesToolkit/st/ to MetadataServicesToolkit/pub/)

Yes, we are using "MetadataServicesToolkit/pub/" URL.

3) Do you still see this problem?

We do not see this recently but it will happen again...

4) Do you know how to reproduce this problem?

We are sorry but we cannot reproduce this again...

We are not sure but this problem may be happen while MST is processing another job. e.g. Harvesting from the OAI-Toolkit

This is idea base but to avoid this, it might be efficient to stop confirming "format" or "set" when harvesting if the harvesting process include this checking. Does this make sense?

Thanks.

Shin Kataoka

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: jbrand JIRA Timestamp: 2012-04-13 06:46 PM

Comment body:

We have recently had this problem in-house. Peter tried to harvest from an MST Ralph set up but failed due to this problem.

Ralph is the system still up that exhibits the problem?

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: admin JIRA Timestamp: 2012-04-16 02:36 PM

Comment body:

I haven't tried it again, but I haven't made any changes to the MST. I assume that it should still not be working.

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Coment by user: rcook JIRA Timestamp: 2012-04-17 04:58 PM

Comment body:

Bumping up per John's input.

____Below From email thread__

I just stumbled upon this and realized it is the same problem we recently had with Peter trying to harvest from an XC MST as directed by Ralph.

Given that this is a known problem, and it has now shown up several times, we should probably bump up the priority.

If and when I find the e-mail about the harvesting problem Peter had, I'll send a similar reply to that. e-mail thread.

There is a fogbugz issue open and here it is: http://xcfogbugz.lib.rochester.edu/default.asp?629

We should update it with the information from Ralph's system and if that MST still has the problem this might be a golden opportunity to figure out what is going wrong.

Thanks very much for your reply. I am trying to use the mailing list for future discussions, so I am adding it there , and I removed your private e-mail addresses from the message. I agree that the problem will be back. We will try to figure out how to recreate it.

Thanks for your comments.

Best Regards, John Brand

On Tue, Nov 15, 2011 at 5:53 AM, Shin Kataoka <...> wrote: Hello John,

I am very sorry to have kept you waiting. It had been tough days this Autumn...

I would like to pass information from Takashi although there includes some ambiguous things.

1) Have you seen this problem? Yes, we have.

2) If so, were you using the proper URL? (It changed from MetadataServicesToolkit/st/ to MetadataServicesToolkit/pub/) Yes, we are using "MetadataServicesToolkit/pub/" URL.

3) Do you still see this problem? We do not see this recently but it will happen again...

4) Do you know how to reproduce this problem? We are sorry but we cannot reproduce this again...

We are not sure but this problem may be happen while MST is processing another job. e.g. Harvesting from the OAI-Toolkit

This is idea base but to avoid this, it might be efficient to stop confirming "format" or "set" when harvesting if the harvesting process include this checking. Does this make sense?

Thanks.

patrickzurek commented 8 years ago

JIRA Comment by user: Chris Delis (cedelis) JIRA Timestamp: 2012-04-17 06:51 PM

Comment body:

Does someone have a known URL for a repo that is still not working correctly? FYI, the following does seem to return valid results:

http://xc-demo.carli.illinois.edu:8080/MetadataServicesToolkit/st/marctoxctransformation/oaiRepository?verb=ListMetadataFormats

Does the problem only occur when the MST is busy harvesting?

Thanks, Chris