search

ea-east / east-biblio

Bibliographic data for EAST
Creative Commons Attribution Share Alike 4.0 International
0 stars 2 forks source link

Wrong association of NB(t) with publication Stcherbatsky 1918 #11

Closed kellner closed 4 years ago

kellner commented 4 years ago

https://east.ikga.oeaw.ac.at/buddh/ind/7/179/: Stcherbatsky's 1918 edition of NB and NBṬ is marked as a full edition of the Tibetan translation, but this is incorrect because it only contains the Sanskrit text. Also, the bibliographical data is wrong; it lists as publisher "Gerold" (?). Correct: publication place = Petrograd, publisher = "Izd. Akademii Nauk" (cross-check this with SUEBS).

paddymcall commented 4 years ago

This should correspond to SUEBS entry 7.4.T2, which is Stcherbatsky's 1904 edition of the NB and its ṭīkā, in Tibetan. I.e., the relation is right, but the date, place, and publisher are wrong in EAST's bibliography. A scan is here: https://archive.org/details/nyayabind00dhar/

JamieCreek commented 4 years ago

https://east.ikga.oeaw.ac.at/buddh/ind/7/23/716/ I guess this entry (east:5508) has the same problem. The publisher (listed again as "Gerold") and place of publication should be Petrograd 1922, Pamyatmiki indiskoi filosofii 1. This should correspond to SUEBS 7.8.r1.

paddymcall commented 4 years ago

The entries got mixed together: Stcherbatsky 1904 (correct title) and Stcherbatsky 1918, corresponding to 7.4.S2. Please add the latter to the bibliography, @JamieCreek.

paddymcall commented 4 years ago

Closed with issue #13.