earlyprint / earlyprint.github.io

Homepage for the EarlyPrint Project: Curating and Exploring Early Printed English
https://earlyprint.org/
2 stars 2 forks source link

publicizing of corrections #20

Open martinmueller39 opened 4 years ago

martinmueller39 commented 4 years ago

I keep thinking about our equivalent of the papyrologists' Berichtigungsliste (correction list), especially in light Joe's recent email about doing something at the MLA. As I've said before, I have a list, by now not quite 100,000 entries. It is kept on a Postgres database (I access it via Aquafold's Data Studio). It is a flat table with a wordid, and columns for curator, edit_type, status, defective_reading, corrected_reading and left as well as right context. It is not hard for me to imagine a Web implementation that supports sorting by any of these columns as well as group by operations. For istance the list below is a simple group by query that returns the 100 texts with the largest number of corrections. Building this is beyond my skillset, but I think it is well within the skillset of anybody who has worked with flask or Django. If we are successful the list would grow into the low millions, but a while it would work with a system that can scale up into the low six figures. I don't know whether one could implement this just as a webstie that uses javascript for sorting and grouping. My general sense is that if something falls squarely into the comfort zone of a relational database, that environment is the most robust and scales easily.

Below is the list. It's just as a easy to construct a list that has all of Elisabeth's corrections of Gerard. The titles with no curators come from the SHC corpus . I don't have records associating individual correctios with particular curators, but I have records that associate each text with one or more curators.

elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A01622 The herball or Generall historie of plantes. Gathered by Iohn Gerarde of London Master in Chirurgerie very much enlarged and amended by Thomas Iohnson 9912 martin A00440 The auncient ecclesiasticall histories of the first six hundred yeares after Christ, wrytten in the Greeke tongue by three learned historiographers, E 3859 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A19821 The ciuile wares betweene the howses of Lancaster and Yorke corrected and continued by Samuel Daniel one of the groomes of hir Maiesties most honorabl 1555 (null) A50091 The excellent comedy, called The old law: or A new way to please you. By Phil. Massinger. Tho. Middleton. William Rowley. Acted before the King and Qu 1436 (null) A11909 Seneca his tenne tragedies, translated into Englysh. 1328 (null) A02827 Apollo shrouing composed for the schollars of the free-schoole of Hadleigh in Suffolke. And acted by them on Shrouetuesday, being the sixt of February 988 skyemccoy2021 A12777 The faerie queene. Disposed into twelue books, fashioning XII. morall vertues. 941 (null) A03201 The fair maid of the vvest. Or, A girle worth gold. The first part. As it was lately acted before the King and Queen, with approved liking. By the Que 871 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A66450 A key into the language of America: or, An help to the language of the natives in that part of America, called New-England. Together, with briefe obse 813 (null) A68114 The tragedy of Selimus Emperour of the Turkes. Written T.G. 790 (null) A16924 The northern lasse, a comoedie. As it hath beene often acted with good applause, at the Globe, and Black-Fryers. By his Maiesties Servants. VVritten b 776 (null) A18413 The gentleman vsher. By George Chapman. 748 (null) A27177 Comedies and tragedies written by Francis Beaumont and Iohn Fletcher Gentlemen. Neverprinted [sic] before, and now published by the authours originall 709 (null) A03224 The first and second partes of King Edward the Fourth. Containing his mery pastime with the tanner of Tamworth, as also his loue to faire Mistrisse Sh 684 (null) A11146 When you see me, you know me. Or the famous chronicle historie of King Henry the eight, with the birth and vertuous life of Edward Prince of Wales. As 671 (null) A03255 The vvise-woman of Hogsdon. A comedie. As it hath been sundry times acted with great applause. Written by Tho: Heyvvood. 658 (null) A03223 The iron age: contayning the rape of Hellen: the siege of Troy: the combate between Hector and Aiax: Hector and Troilus slayne by Achilles: Achilles s 652 (null) A09224 The famous chronicle of king Edward the first, sirnamed Edward Longshankes, with his returne from the holy land. Also the life of Lleuellen rebell in 626 caseywells2022 A03235 Loves maistresse: or, The Queens masque. As it was three times presented before their two Excellent Maiesties, within the space of eight dayes; in the 625 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A12024 The late, and much admired play, called Pericles, Prince of Tyre. With the true relation of the whole historie, aduentures, and fortunes of the said p 590 (null) A20096 The famous history of Sir Thomas VVyat. With the coronation of Queen Mary, and the coming in of King Philip. As it was plaied by the Queens Maiesties 581 (null) A04539 The Diuils charter: a tragædie conteining the life and death of Pope Alexander the sixt. As it was plaide before the Kings Maiestie, vpon Candlemasse 576 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A00991 A vvorlde of wordes, or Most copious, and exact dictionarie in Italian and English, collected by Iohn Florio. 569 (null) A20081 Satiro--mastix. Or The vntrussing of the humorous poet. As it hath bin presented publikely, by the Right Honorable, the Lord Chamberlaine his seruants 563 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A39803 Fathers own son. A comedy. Formerly acted at the private house in Black Fryers; and now at the Theatre in Vere-street by His Majesties servants. The a 549 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A61310 The step-mother, a tragi-comedy, acted with great applause at the theatre in Little Lincolns-Inn-Fields, by His Highness the Duke of York's servants. 546 (null) A18423 Tvvo vvise men and all the rest fooles: or A comicall morall, censuring the follies of this age, as it hath beene diverse times acted. 543 (null) A20066 If it be not good, the Diuel is in it. A nevv play, as it hath bin lately acted, vvith great applause, by the Queenes Maiesties Seruants: at the Red B 537 (null) A01046 The broken heart. A tragedy. Acted by the Kings Majesties Seruants at the priuate House in the Black-Friers. 532 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A00969 The two noble kinsmen: presented at the Blackfriers by the Kings Maiesties servants, with great applause: written by the memorable worthies of their t 505 (null) A12969 A ryght pithy, pleasaunt and merie comedie: intytuled Gammer gurtons nedle: played on stage, not longe a go in Christes Colledge in Cambridge. Made by 499 (null) A01520 The glasse of gouernement. A tragicall comedie so entituled, bycause therein are handled aswell the rewardes for vertues, as also the punishment for v 487 (null) A00979 Sicelides a piscatory, as it hath beene acted in Kings Colledge, in Cambridge. 486 (null) A18729 A discourse of the Queenes Maiesties entertainement in Suffolk and Norffolk: with a description of many things then presently seene. Deuised by Thomas 461 (null) A07065 The Dutch courtezan. As it vvas playd in the Blacke-Friars, by the Children of her Maiesties Reuels. VVritten by Iohn Marston. 459 autocorrect A16049 The Nevv Testament of Iesus Christ, translated faithfully into English, out of the authentical Latin, according to the best corrected copies of the sa 458 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A27287 The Dutch lover: a comedy, acted at the Dukes theatre. Written by Mrs. A. Bhen [sic]. 448 (null) A77567 Five nevv playes, viz. The English moor, or the mock-marriage. The love-sick court, or the ambitious politique. Covent Garden weeded. The nevv academy 448 (null) A03258 The late Lancashire vvitches. A well received comedy, lately acted at the Globe on the Banke-side, by the Kings Majesties Actors. Written, by Thom. He 443 (null) A06389 The scornful ladie. A comedie. As it was acted (with great applause) by the Children of Her Maiesties Reuels in the Blacke Fryers. Written byFra. Beau 441 (null) A01911 Sir Gyles Goosecappe Knight. A comedie presented by the Chil: of the Chappell. 440 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A16049 The Nevv Testament of Iesus Christ, translated faithfully into English, out of the authentical Latin, according to the best corrected copies of the sa 433 (null) A12145 The maides revenge. A tragedy. As it hath beene acted with good applause at the private house in Drury Lane, by her Majesties Servants· VVritten by Ia 429 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A50949 The reason of church-governement urg'd against prelaty by Mr. John Milton. In two books. 422 (null) A12954 Cinthia's reuenge: or Mænanders extasie. 416 (null) A03244 The rape of Lucrece. A true Roman tragedie. With the seuerall songes in their apt places, by Valerius, the merrie lord amongst the Roman peeres. Acted 405 (null) A07251 The fatall dovvry: a tragedy. As it hath beene often acted at the Priuate House in Blackefryers, by his Maiesties Seruants. Written by P.M. and N.F. 400 (null) A11264 The puritaine or The vviddovv of VVatling-streete. Acted by the Children of Paules. Written by W.S. 399 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A59422 The history of Timon of Athens, the man-hater. As it is acted at the Dukes Theatre. Made into a play· By Tho. Shadwell. Licensed, Feb. 18. 1678/7. Ro. 375 (null) A18419 A pleasant comedy entituled: An humerous dayes myrth. As it hath beene sundrie times publikely acted by the right honourable the Earle of Nottingham L 374 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A20092 The vvhore of Babylon. As it was acted by the Princes Seruants. Written by Thomas Dekker. 371 (null) A12155 The vvedding. As it was lately acted by her Maiesties Seruants, at the Phenix in Drury Lane. Written by Iames Shirley, Gent. 370 (null) A53060 Playes written by the thrice noble, illustrious and excellent princess, the Lady Marchioness of Nevvcastle. 361 (null) A06402 The phaenix in her flames. A tragedy. The scene, Arabia. The author, Master William Lower. 359 (null) A31675 The tragedy of Alphonsus Emperour of Germany as it hath been very often acted (with great applause) at the privat house in Black-Friers by his late Ma 353 (null) A07240 The maid of honour. As it hath beene often presented with good allowance at the Phœnix in Drurie-Lane, by the Queenes Majesties Servants. Written by P 343 (null) A01047 The chronicle historie of Perkin VVarbeck. A strange truth. Acted (some-times) by the Queenes Maiesties Servants at the Phænix in Drurie lane. 341 (null) A12150 The royall master; as it vvas acted in the nevv Theater in Dublin: and before the Right Honorable the Lord Deputie of Ireland, in the Castle. Written 333 (null) A12023 The London prodigall. As it was plaide by the Kings Maiesties seruants. By VVilliam Shakespeare, 331 (null) A12074 Cupids vvhirligig. As it hath bene sundry times acted by the Children of the Kings Majesties Reuels. 325 autocorrect A16144 The effect of certaine sermons touching the full redemption of mankind by the death and bloud of Christ Iesus: wherein besides the merite of Christs s 323 autocorrect A68413 The first booke of the historie of the discouerie and conquest of the East Indias, enterprised by the Portingales, in their daungerous nauigations, in 319 (null) A49479 Lusts dominion; or, the lascivious queen. A tragedie. Written by Christofer Marloe, Gent. 317 (null) A01853 The tragedie of Lodouick Sforza Duke of Millan. By Robert Gomersall. 312 (null) A77565 Five new playes, (viz.) The madd couple well matcht. Novella. Court begger. City witt. Damoiselle. By Richard Brome. 312 (null) A07071 The malcontent. By Iohn Marston. 1604. 311 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A05303 A treatise of specters or straunge sights, visions and apparitions appearing sensibly vnto men. Wherein is delivered, the nature of spirites, angels, 305 johnmayer2021 A35565 A treatise concerning enthusiasme, as it is an effect of nature: but is mistaken by many for either divine inspiration, or diabolical possession. By M 303 skyemccoy2021 A86558 Selected parts of Horace, prince of lyricks; and of all the Latin poets the fullest fraught with excellent morality.: Concluding with a piece out of 300 (null) A07245 The picture a tragæcomædie, as it was often presented with good allowance, at the Globe, and Blackefriers play-houses, by the Kings Maiesties seruants 299 autocorrect A00991 A vvorlde of wordes, or Most copious, and exact dictionarie in Italian and English, collected by Iohn Florio. 298 (null) A07217 The Turke. A worthie tragedie. As it hath bene diuers times acted by the Children of his Maiesties Reuels. Written by Iohn Mason Maister of Artes. 297 (null) A18402 The blinde begger of Alexandria, most pleasantly discoursing his variable humours in disguised shapes full of conceite and pleasure. As it hath been s 295 (null) A43595 Fortune by land and sea. A tragi-comedy. As it was acted with great applause by the Queens servants. Written by Tho. Haywood and William Rowly. 285 (null) A09857 The pleasant history of the two angry women of Abington. With the humorous mirth of Dicke Coomes and Nicholas Prouerbes, tvvo seruingmen. As it was la 283 (null) A11151 A match at mid-night. A pleasant comœdie: as it hath beene acted by the Children of the Revells. Written by VV.R. 280 (null) A18400 Al fooles a comedy, presented at the Black Fryers, and lately before his Maiestie. Written by George Chapman. 280 autocorrect A59088 Of the dominion, or, ownership of the sea two books. In the first is shew'd, that the sea, by the lavv of nature, or nations. [sic] is not common to a 278 (null) A09220 The araygnement of Paris a pastorall. Presented before the Queenes Maiestie, by the Children of her chappell. 278 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A17706 Sermons of M. Iohn Caluine vpon the Epistle of Saincte Paule to the Galathians. 272 (null) A03202 The foure prentises of London. VVith the conquest of Ierusalem. As it hath bene diuerse times acted, at the Red Bull, by the Queenes Maiesties Seruant 271 (null) A07247 The Roman actor. A tragædie. As it hath diuers times beene, with good allowance acted, at the private play-house in the Black-Friers, by the Kings Maj 271 (null) A01773 The Hollander. A comedy written 1635. The author Henry Glapthorne. And now printed as it was then acted at the Cock-pit in Drury lane, by their Majest 269 (null) A07248 The unnaturall combat. A tragedie. The scæne Marsellis. Written by Philip Massinger. As it was presented by the Kings Majesties Servants at the Globe. 268 (null) A12140 Hide Parke a comedie, as it vvas presented by her Majesties Servants, at the private house in Drury Lane. Written by Iames Shirly. 264 elisabeth.chaghafi@uni-tuebingen.de A12010 An excellent conceited tragedie of Romeo and Iuliet. As it hath been often (with great applause) plaid publiquely, by the right Honourable the L. of H 263 (null) A15519 A right excellent and famous comedy, called The three ladies of London. VVherein is notablie declared and set forth, how by the meanes of lucar, loue 263 (null) A04658 The nevv inne. Or, The light heart. A comoedy. As it was neuer acted, but most negligently play'd, by some, the Kings Seruants. And more squeamishly b 260 autocorrect A05303 A treatise of specters or straunge sights, visions and apparitions appearing sensibly vnto men. Wherein is delivered, the nature of spirites, angels, 254 skyemccoy2021 A65360 Appius and Virginia. A tragedy. By John Webster. 253 (null) A00962 The faithfull shepheardesse. By Iohn Fletcher. 253 (null) A06207 A king and no king. Acted at the Globe, by his Maiesties Seruants. Written by Francis Beamount, and Iohn Flecher. 253 (null) A11262 The lamentable tragedie of Locrine, the eldest sonne of King Brutus, discoursing the warres of the Britaines, and Hunnes, with their discomfiture: the 253 (null) A04632 The workes of Beniamin Ionson. 252 johnmayer2021 B00290 The booke of the common prayer, and adminystracion of the sacramentes, and other rytes, and ceremonies in the Churche of Englande. 249

jrladd commented 4 years ago

I very much like the idea of having a page to show the changes made in the last year. The fact that they're already in Postgres DB makes this relatively simple.

However, rather than build a bit of Django or Flask infrastructure to have this page live-generate from a database, I'd prefer to have it be something static that we can occasionally update (maybe once a quarter or once a year) with minimal headaches. I would propose that someone write a short script that generates an attractively-formatted static page that shows the recent changes in a way that plays nicely with the Github site. We can store that script in this github.io repo, so that we can easily run it again whenever we choose to regenerate the page.

This option creates minimal overhead and fewer dependencies for us to look after in the long term. It will require a human person to regenerate the page occasionally, but a Django or Flask app will also require human maintenance (and likely more time and energy in the long run).

dknoxwu commented 4 years ago

I like the big-picture vision of drawing attention to recent contributions, and recording contributions altogether.

May I throw in two additional questions and concerns?

1) Apart from the question of presentational technologies, I'd like to ask how this will work as long-term data. If as a data consumer, rather than as a web consumer, I get a current annotated TCP XML file from the repository and I'd like the project's most authoritative information on the history of changes to that file, can I get an XML or CSV file of changes from a repository that has a similar kind of expectation of long-term management?

The record of changes is important project data, and it's too important to live solely inside a single application; it doesn't seem "real" in a durable way until it follows a path out of the application.

2) Does anyone else share a sense of risk in committing to a public record of credit where individuals are identified by email address or by eXist account handle, and where those handles look like, or are, email addresses?

* Not everyone who wants to contribute will necessarily want to make their email address public

* Email addresses often change, especially handles provided by educational institutions to undergraduates, like "givensurname2021"

It would be great to give undergraduates and others credit for contributions to a research corpus, and it would be especially nice if current undergraduates are interested enough to continue making contributions after they graduate.

But participants should know what they are getting into and explicitly approve the release of publicly identifying information about them. I don't know much about FERPA or GDPR, but understand the general intent. Isn't this the sort of thing where a little more consultation or anticipation of such issues could go a long way?

On 11/4/19 11:17 AM, JR Ladd wrote:

I very much like the idea of having a page to show the changes made in the last year. The fact that they're already in Postgres DB makes this relatively simple.

However, rather than build a bit of Django or Flask infrastructure to have this page live-generate from a database, I'd prefer to have it be something static that we can occasionally update (maybe once a quarter or once a year) with minimal headaches. I would propose that someone write a short script that generates an attractively-formatted static page that shows the recent changes in a way that plays nicely with the Github site. We can store that script in this github.io repo, so that we can easily run it again whenever we choose to regenerate the page.

This option creates minimal overhead and fewer dependencies for us to look after in the long term. It will require a human person to regenerate the page occasionally, but a Django or Flask app will also require human maintenance (and likely more time and energy in the long run).

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io/issues/20?email_source=notifications&email_token=ALY7TCUA5NBR3YMVGE55VUTQSBKLJA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAAXVY#issuecomment-549456855, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALY7TCS2PEKRP4V6D4K7WJLQSBKLJANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ.

jfloewen commented 4 years ago

Names and institutions without emails? Opt-out on publication at registration?

On Nov 4, 2019, at 11:52 AM, dknoxwu notifications@github.com<mailto:notifications@github.com> wrote:

I like the big-picture vision of drawing attention to recent contributions, and recording contributions altogether.

May I throw in two additional questions and concerns?

1) Apart from the question of presentational technologies, I'd like to ask how this will work as long-term data. If as a data consumer, rather than as a web consumer, I get a current annotated TCP XML file from the repository and I'd like the project's most authoritative information on the history of changes to that file, can I get an XML or CSV file of changes from a repository that has a similar kind of expectation of long-term management?

The record of changes is important project data, and it's too important to live solely inside a single application; it doesn't seem "real" in a durable way until it follows a path out of the application.

2) Does anyone else share a sense of risk in committing to a public record of credit where individuals are identified by email address or by eXist account handle, and where those handles look like, or are, email addresses?

It would be great to give undergraduates and others credit for contributions to a research corpus, and it would be especially nice if current undergraduates are interested enough to continue making contributions after they graduate.

But participants should know what they are getting into and explicitly approve the release of publicly identifying information about them. I don't know much about FERPA or GDPR, but understand the general intent. Isn't this the sort of thing where a little more consultation or anticipation of such issues could go a long way?

On 11/4/19 11:17 AM, JR Ladd wrote:

I very much like the idea of having a page to show the changes made in the last year. The fact that they're already in Postgres DB makes this relatively simple.

However, rather than build a bit of Django or Flask infrastructure to have this page live-generate from a database, I'd prefer to have it be something static that we can occasionally update (maybe once a quarter or once a year) with minimal headaches. I would propose that someone write a short script that generates an attractively-formatted static page that shows the recent changes in a way that plays nicely with the Github site. We can store that script in this github.iohttp://github.io repo, so that we can easily run it again whenever we choose to regenerate the page.

This option creates minimal overhead and fewer dependencies for us to look after in the long term. It will require a human person to regenerate the page occasionally, but a Django or Flask app will also require human maintenance (and likely more time and energy in the long run).

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io/issues/20?email_source=notifications&email_token=ALY7TCUA5NBR3YMVGE55VUTQSBKLJA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAAXVY#issuecomment-549456855, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALY7TCS2PEKRP4V6D4K7WJLQSBKLJANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io/issues/20?email_source=notifications&email_token=AMBORAVDFVT5HZHZ34SSECLQSBOOPA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAEF3Q#issuecomment-549470958, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMBORAWHXBR2GJF6NR6A5DDQSBOOPANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ.

craigberry commented 4 years ago

We have a lot of changes we want to make to the registration process but I can't promise when they will be done and they won't help us with the data we already have.  For that we don't actually have names; we only have e-mail addresses.  I suspect our collective memories could reconstruct names for nearly all the contributors, but it's slipping away if we don't do it soon.

On November 4, 2019 at 12:07 PM, jfloewen notifications@github.com wrote:

Names and institutions without emails? Opt-out on publication at registration?

On Nov 4, 2019, at 11:52 AM, dknoxwu notifications@github.com<mailto:notifications@github.com> wrote:

I like the big-picture vision of drawing attention to recent contributions, and recording contributions altogether.

May I throw in two additional questions and concerns?

1) Apart from the question of presentational technologies, I'd like to ask how this will work as long-term data. If as a data consumer, rather than as a web consumer, I get a current annotated TCP XML file from the repository and I'd like the project's most authoritative information on the history of changes to that file, can I get an XML or CSV file of changes from a repository that has a similar kind of expectation of long-term management?

The record of changes is important project data, and it's too important to live solely inside a single application; it doesn't seem "real" in a durable way until it follows a path out of the application.

2) Does anyone else share a sense of risk in committing to a public record of credit where individuals are identified by email address or by eXist account handle, and where those handles look like, or are, email addresses?

It would be great to give undergraduates and others credit for contributions to a research corpus, and it would be especially nice if current undergraduates are interested enough to continue making contributions after they graduate.

But participants should know what they are getting into and explicitly approve the release of publicly identifying information about them. I don't know much about FERPA or GDPR, but understand the general intent. Isn't this the sort of thing where a little more consultation or anticipation of such issues could go a long way?

On 11/4/19 11:17 AM, JR Ladd wrote:

I very much like the idea of having a page to show the changes made in the last year. The fact that they're already in Postgres DB makes this relatively simple.

However, rather than build a bit of Django or Flask infrastructure to have this page live-generate from a database, I'd prefer to have it be something static that we can occasionally update (maybe once a quarter or once a year) with minimal headaches. I would propose that someone write a short script that generates an attractively-formatted static page that shows the recent changes in a way that plays nicely with the Github site. We can store that script in this github.iohttp://github.io repo, so that we can easily run it again whenever we choose to regenerate the page.

This option creates minimal overhead and fewer dependencies for us to look after in the long term. It will require a human person to regenerate the page occasionally, but a Django or Flask app will also require human maintenance (and likely more time and energy in the long run).

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io/issues/20?email_source=notifications&email_token=ALY7TCUA5NBR3YMVGE55VUTQSBKLJA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAAXVY#issuecomment-549456855, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALY7TCS2PEKRP4V6D4K7WJLQSBKLJANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io/issues/20?email_source=notifications&email_token=AMBORAVDFVT5HZHZ34SSECLQSBOOPA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAEF3Q#issuecomment-549470958, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMBORAWHXBR2GJF6NR6A5DDQSBOOPANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

martinmueller39 commented 4 years ago

I completely agree that it would be inappropriate to have email addresses on a public correction list. It just so happens that my current list has them because that is how the current registration handles them

From: "Craig A. Berry" notifications@github.com Reply-To: "earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io" reply@reply.github.com Date: Monday, November 4, 2019 at 12:22 PM To: "earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io" earlyprint.github.io@noreply.github.com Cc: Martin Mueller martinmueller@northwestern.edu, Author author@noreply.github.com Subject: Re: [earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io] publicizing of corrections (#20)

We have a lot of changes we want to make to the registration process but I can't promise when they will be done and they won't help us with the data we already have. For that we don't actually have names; we only have e-mail addresses. I suspect our collective memories could reconstruct names for nearly all the contributors, but it's slipping away if we don't do it soon.

On November 4, 2019 at 12:07 PM, jfloewen notifications@github.com wrote:

Names and institutions without emails? Opt-out on publication at registration?

On Nov 4, 2019, at 11:52 AM, dknoxwu notifications@github.com<mailto:notifications@github.com> wrote:

I like the big-picture vision of drawing attention to recent contributions, and recording contributions altogether.

May I throw in two additional questions and concerns?

1) Apart from the question of presentational technologies, I'd like to ask how this will work as long-term data. If as a data consumer, rather than as a web consumer, I get a current annotated TCP XML file from the repository and I'd like the project's most authoritative information on the history of changes to that file, can I get an XML or CSV file of changes from a repository that has a similar kind of expectation of long-term management?

The record of changes is important project data, and it's too important to live solely inside a single application; it doesn't seem "real" in a durable way until it follows a path out of the application.

2) Does anyone else share a sense of risk in committing to a public record of credit where individuals are identified by email address or by eXist account handle, and where those handles look like, or are, email addresses?

It would be great to give undergraduates and others credit for contributions to a research corpus, and it would be especially nice if current undergraduates are interested enough to continue making contributions after they graduate.

But participants should know what they are getting into and explicitly approve the release of publicly identifying information about them. I don't know much about FERPA or GDPR, but understand the general intent. Isn't this the sort of thing where a little more consultation or anticipation of such issues could go a long way?

On 11/4/19 11:17 AM, JR Ladd wrote:

I very much like the idea of having a page to show the changes made in the last year. The fact that they're already in Postgres DB makes this relatively simple.

However, rather than build a bit of Django or Flask infrastructure to have this page live-generate from a database, I'd prefer to have it be something static that we can occasionally update (maybe once a quarter or once a year) with minimal headaches. I would propose that someone write a short script that generates an attractively-formatted static page that shows the recent changes in a way that plays nicely with the Github site. We can store that script in this github.iohttp://github.io repo, so that we can easily run it again whenever we choose to regenerate the page.

This option creates minimal overhead and fewer dependencies for us to look after in the long term. It will require a human person to regenerate the page occasionally, but a Django or Flask app will also require human maintenance (and likely more time and energy in the long run).

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io/issues/20?email_source=notifications&email_token=ALY7TCUA5NBR3YMVGE55VUTQSBKLJA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAAXVY#issuecomment-549456855, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALY7TCS2PEKRP4V6D4K7WJLQSBKLJANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/earlyprint/earlyprint.github.io/issues/20?email_source=notifications&email_token=AMBORAVDFVT5HZHZ34SSECLQSBOOPA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAEF3Q#issuecomment-549470958, or unsubscribehttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AMBORAWHXBR2GJF6NR6A5DDQSBOOPANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ.

— You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__github.com_earlyprint_earlyprint.github.io_issues_20-3Femail-5Fsource-3Dnotifications-26email-5Ftoken-3DABL7UL4YUNRKAP76STDS6HLQSBR7JA5CNFSM4JIU5LL2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFVREXG43VMVBW63LNMVXHJKTDN5WW2ZLOORPWSZGOEDAHHDQ-23issuecomment-2D549483406&d=DwMFaQ&c=yHlS04HhBraes5BQ9ueu5zKhE7rtNXt_d012z2PA6ws&r=rG8zxOdssqSzDRz4x1GLlmLOW60xyVXydxwnJZpkxbk&m=GGGMXXY-t8TldBdpoyD1n9HLd3N-jpgfYI4odFG96vs&s=qBXg1IQ7KYP3ARokEJVU9bcBB9ak_6PdNUpXn_2bWf4&e=, or unsubscribehttps://urldefense.proofpoint.com/v2/url?u=https-3A__github.com_notifications_unsubscribe-2Dauth_ABL7UL5SPDB2MMRPM23GAATQSBR7JANCNFSM4JIU5LLQ&d=DwMFaQ&c=yHlS04HhBraes5BQ9ueu5zKhE7rtNXt_d012z2PA6ws&r=rG8zxOdssqSzDRz4x1GLlmLOW60xyVXydxwnJZpkxbk&m=GGGMXXY-t8TldBdpoyD1n9HLd3N-jpgfYI4odFG96vs&s=mEr12_nNzJMmJ9BkuJI0NoHuGj_OjYTZdDXIsPEaKek&e=.