search

ease-crc / soma

The Socio-physical Model of Activities (SOMA) is a formal activity model for embodied agents that need to operate their body to generate motions that cause intentional effects in the physical and social world.
GNU Lesser General Public License v3.0
16 stars 22 forks source link

results of ontology evaluation with OOPS! #21

Closed mcodescu closed 4 years ago

mcodescu commented 5 years ago

I have tested the ontologies with the evaluation tool OOPS! (http://oops.linkeddata.es), that detects common problems in the ontologies. For the modules, there was virtually no problem reported. For the EASE ontology (https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ease-crc/ease_ontology/master/owl/EASE.owl in the Scanner by URI), the tool made however a number of suggestions, e.g. missing domain and range axioms, or using recursive definitions. The tool does not provide a txt export from the web results, so you would have to run the check again (does not take long) to have a look at them and consider whether their suggestions should be followed or not.

mpomarlan commented 5 years ago

I've saved the html of the results, so anyone interested can download them and have a look:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1T3k_6zR2n6Bvp3KrBqHYePTn8GWVgqOq/view?usp=sharing

daniel86 commented 5 years ago

would it be possible to include such tests in travis CI? That would be cool, I think

mcodescu commented 5 years ago

I'd say the reported issues are a matter of interpretation in many cases (you might have a reason not to add a domain axiom for a property) and should not be part of a mandatory test. Maybe one idea would be to require that no critical issues are reported.

OOPS! is available as a RESTful service so it should be possible to write a script that runs the test on a given ontology and interprets the results.

mpomarlan commented 5 years ago

As long as we can suppress certain warnings. Not the warning type in general, but a particular warning, caused by a particular part of the ontology. A lot of the OOPS warnings are actually caused by DUL (ba-dum-tish).