search

ecatch-kyst / web

IT Bachelor project @ NTNU ⚡🎣
https://ecatch-kyst-beta.firebaseapp.com
GNU General Public License v3.0
5 stars 0 forks source link

🤯 Reminder to set Lighthouse threshold parameters #5

Closed balazsorban44 closed 5 years ago

balazsorban44 commented 5 years ago

Description

As of now, @lighthousebot has no real thresholds set. We should figure out some good values/goals we should aim for, and set those in .travis.yml

Idea :bulb:: Check out some well-built, known PWAs' scores, and post them here in comments in the form of.:

Website: http://example.com

Category Score
Performance x
Progressive Web App x
Accessibility x
Best Practices x
SEO x

(score template here)

@ecatch-kyst/frontend

balazsorban44 commented 5 years ago

@ecatch-kyst/frontend

elfingar commented 5 years ago

I've looked into it a bit. I dont have any pwa examples, but from what i have read it seems like 80 is considered a good score and anything below means it can be optimized further. I dont know if that is an unrealistic goal or not to follow.

toretefre commented 5 years ago

Website: http://dev.opera.com

Category Score
Performance 95
Progressive Web App 81
Accessibility 76
Best Practices 93
SEO 100

Website: http://forbes.com

Category Score
Performance 32
Progressive Web App 31
Accessibility 87
Best Practices 73
SEO 100

Website: http://instagram.com

Category Score
Performance 58
Progressive Web App 62
Accessibility 77
Best Practices 100
SEO 80

Website: http://maps.google.com

Category Score
Performance 81
Progressive Web App 65
Accessibility 86
Best Practices 87
SEO 80

Website: http://offline-dino-game.firebaseapp.com

Category Score
Performance 100
Progressive Web App 100
Accessibility 93
Best Practices 87
SEO 91

Website: http://www.currency-calc.com/

Category Score
Performance 94
Progressive Web App 100
Accessibility 46
Best Practices 87
SEO 100
toretefre commented 5 years ago

Maybe we can try to beat Instagram on all fields except for Best Practices where we can aim for 75-80 which seems to be realistic?

toretefre commented 5 years ago

eCatch Kyst Target? Website: http://ecatch-kyst-beta.firebaseapp.com

Category Score
Performance 60
Progressive Web App 60
Accessibility 80
Best Practices 70
SEO 80
balazsorban44 commented 5 years ago

On Progressive Web App and Best Practices we can aim for 100, I think. PWA at least, since we build a PWA! In our case, SEO is much less important than best practices also, in my opinion. We don't have to "appeal" to anybody with our product, the main audition won't come through search engines.

EDIT:

My recommendation:

(using averages of the previous comment's results for Performance, and Accessibility)

eCatch Kyst Website: http://ecatch-kyst-beta.firebaseapp.com

Category Score
Performance 77
Progressive Web App 100
Accessibility 78
Best Practices 100
SEO 1
toretefre commented 5 years ago

Closed in PR #44