edwardkort / WWIDesigner

Wood Wind Instrument Designer
43 stars 8 forks source link

Fingering Pattern #48

Closed JRSflyer closed 8 years ago

JRSflyer commented 8 years ago

Ed Finally getting the hang of the software.
Suggestion in the next revision: When we create a fingering pattern in the tuning wizard it would be nice to have the weight column so we can enter our weighs and save them with the pattern. Every time we open our tuning files, we have to add the same weights since we use the same ones 99% of the time. It would be a time saver. Thanks for your time.

Rick

edwardkort commented 8 years ago

Rick,

When you open your tuning file in the Editor pane, and then make changes (weights, fingering, frequency, or name), just go to the File menu and do a Save or Save as. Those changes will now be persisted and come up the next time you open the tuning file.

We did not expose weights in the Tuning Wizard (instead setting a default value of 1) for several reasons:

  1. The Wizard interface was already very cluttered
  2. Most users would always want a weight of 1 for each fingering
  3. Only the NAF study exposes weights. Changing the weights for a Whistle study would have unintended consequences
  4. Changing weights seemed more of an on-the-fly thing while optimizing a flute. I manipulate the weights a lot when optimizing a particular design, but those changes are unique for that flute - I don't save them
  5. The Save/Save as capability in the Editor pane gives you full persistence capabilities.

Cheers, Edward Kort

JRSflyer commented 8 years ago

I was having no problem with the software, made all my tuning files, and was able to get a fipple factor when I was learning the software. I am tried to do a fipple factor again and followed the directions and the save window will not come on. I have clicked new, added note, and 440, and named the file with a description but the save but the save button remains unlit. any suggestions?

On Fri, Jun 24, 2016 at 10:18 AM, Edward Kort notifications@github.com wrote:

Rick,

When you open your tuning file in the Editor pane, and then make changes (weights, fingering, frequency, or name), just go to the File menu and do a Save or Save as. Those changes will now be persisted and come up the next time you open the tuning file.

We did not expose weights in the Tuning Wizard (instead setting a default value of 1) for several reasons:

  1. The Wizard interface was already very cluttered
  2. Most users would always want a weight of 1 for each fingering
  3. Only the NAF study exposes weights. Changing the weights for a Whistle study would have unintended consequences
  4. Changing weights seemed more of an on-the-fly thing while optimizing a flute. I manipulate the weights a lot when optimizing a particular design, but those changes are unique for that flute - I don't save them
  5. The Save/Save as capability in the Editor pane gives you full persistence capabilities.

Cheers, Edward Kort

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/edwardkort/WWIDesigner/issues/48#issuecomment-228358000, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe/AQX1ZmrfgRkTwHSefihgCsUWAMKBSV4Uks5qO-c2gaJpZM4I9vTe .

edwardkort commented 8 years ago

Rick, After you enter the 440 frequency, you have to either hit ENTER or click on another cell on that fingering line. Otherwise, the program doesn't know you have finished editing - to activate the Save button. You can tell that the 440 has been accepted: the program will append .0000 to your value.

Cheers, Edward Kort