ehealthsuisse / ch-epr-ppqm

PPQ für mobile apps
1 stars 2 forks source link

Change resource profile names #23

Closed unixoid closed 10 months ago

unixoid commented 1 year ago

Resource profile names PpqmRequestBundle and PpqmResponseBundle are unhappy because they look as being request and response messages of the same transaction. In reality, PpqmRequestBundle is used in PPQ-4, and PpqmResponseBundle in PPQ-5. Therefore, they should be renamed e.g. to PpqmFeedRequestBundle and PpqmSearchResponseBundle.

UPD: PpqmRetrieveResponseBundle instead of PpqmSearchResponseBundle.

qligier commented 1 year ago

In the index, PPQ-5 is called "Mobile Privacy Policy Retrieve", not Search, it could be confusing.

I would associate "retrieve" with getting a single resource, so renaming PPQ-5 "Mobile Privacy Policy Search" seems a good solution I think.

unixoid commented 1 year ago

For me, the semantical difference between "search" and "retrieve" is that

In that way, PPQ-5 is for me clearly of the type "retrieve".

qligier commented 1 year ago

In FHIR, search and retrieve are a bit less distinct, because you retrieve when you search. But retrieve is fine, I would suggest using PpqmRetrieveResponseBundle for consistency.

unixoid commented 1 year ago

You are right, thanks.

dkotlaris commented 10 months ago

26.10.2023: Accepted.