Closed veprbl closed 1 month ago
Been experimenting with automated code review. This is what chatgpt gives.
Here is a review of the provided patch:
The patch deprecates the podio:output_include_collections
parameter in favor of podio:output_collections
and makes related code adjustments. It also includes some changes for "Include What You Use" (IWYU) compliance.
podio:output_include_collections
Changes Made:
podio:output_collections
.podio:output_include_collections
parameter, which clears output_collections
if the deprecated parameter is used.Code Review:
m_log->warn
instead of m_log->error
might be more appropriate since it's not an error in the system but a usage warning.Changes Made:
.github/iwyu.imp
to correctly map <bits/chrono.h>
to <chrono>
.Code Review:
warn
:
m_log->warn("The podio:output_include_collections was provided, but is deprecated. Use podio:output_collections instead.");
Overall, the patch is well-constructed, handling the deprecation gracefully while maintaining backward compatibility. The IWYU changes are appropriate and follow best practices. Only minor adjustments regarding logging levels and additional comments are recommended.
if (m_output_include_collections_set) {
m_log->warn("The podio:output_include_collections was provided, but is deprecated. Use podio:output_collections instead.");
// Adding a delay to ensure users notice the deprecation warning.
using namespace std::chrono_literals;
std::this_thread::sleep_for(10s);
}
Great job on the patch!
@wdconinc Ready to approve?
This is a follow up on a resolution from #1323
What kind of change does this PR introduce?
Please check if this PR fulfills the following:
Does this PR introduce breaking changes? What changes might users need to make to their code?
No
Does this PR change default behavior?
No