Values tending to the minimum value when providing `fuzziness` config

[aliabbas-elastic]

• While generating the corpus of events in the Nginx stubstatus data stream, I am seeing the value of a field being set as the minimum value of the range provided after a certain set of documents when fuzziness config is provided.

Attaching the configs used:-

config.yml

fields:
  - name: 'timestamp'
    period: -24h # one day
  - name: agent.id
    value: "ef5e274d-4b53-45e6-943a-a5bcf1a6f523"
  - name: service.address
    enum: ["elastic-package-service-nginx-1","elastic-package-service-nginx-2","elastic-package-service-nginx-3"]
  - name: event.duration
    range:
      min: 1
      max: 1000
  - name: writing
    range:
      min: 1
      max: 100
    fuzziness: 0.6

Attaching the subset corpus generated for 200 events generated. Find the field writing in the corpus generated and it's values generated after a certain set of documents generated.

{    "@timestamp": "2024-01-10T21:38:23.410Z",    "agent": {        "ephemeral_id": "ivorybite",        "id": "ef5e274d-4b53-45e6-943a-a5bcf1a6f523",        "name": "zincbow",        "type": "metricbeat",        "version": "8.8.0"    },    "data_stream": {        "dataset": "nginx.stubstatus",        "namespace": "ep",        "type": "metrics"    },    "ecs": {        "version": "8.5.1"    },    "elastic_agent": {        "id": "ivorybite",        "snapshot": false,        "version": "8.8.0"    },    "event": {        "agent_id_status": "verified",        "dataset": "nginx.stubstatus",        "duration": 58,        "module": "nginx"    },     "host": {        "architecture": "x86_64",        "containerized": false,        "hostname": "docker-fleet-agent",        "id": "66392b0697b84641af8006d87aeb89f1",        "ip": [            "172.18.0.7"        ],        "mac": [            "02-42-AC-12-00-07"        ],        "name": "docker-fleet-agent",        "os": {            "codename": "focal",            "family": "debian",            "kernel": "5.15.49-linuxkit",            "name": "Ubuntu",            "platform": "ubuntu",            "type": "linux",            "version": "20.04.5 LTS (Focal Fossa)"        }    },    "metricset": {        "name": "stubstatus",        "period": 10000    },    "nginx": {        "stubstatus": {            "writing": 1        }    },    "service": {        "address": "http://elastic-package-service-nginx-3:80/server-status",        "type": "nginx"    }}

{    "@timestamp": "2024-01-10T21:45:35.410Z",    "agent": {        "ephemeral_id": "chestnutpanther",        "id": "ef5e274d-4b53-45e6-943a-a5bcf1a6f523",        "name": "rattleoriole",        "type": "metricbeat",        "version": "8.8.0"    },    "data_stream": {        "dataset": "nginx.stubstatus",        "namespace": "ep",        "type": "metrics"    },    "ecs": {        "version": "8.5.1"    },    "elastic_agent": {        "id": "chestnutpanther",        "snapshot": false,        "version": "8.8.0"    },    "event": {        "agent_id_status": "verified",        "dataset": "nginx.stubstatus",        "duration": 472,        "module": "nginx"    },     "host": {        "architecture": "x86_64",        "containerized": false,        "hostname": "docker-fleet-agent",        "id": "66392b0697b84641af8006d87aeb89f1",        "ip": [            "172.18.0.7"        ],        "mac": [            "02-42-AC-12-00-07"        ],        "name": "docker-fleet-agent",        "os": {            "codename": "focal",            "family": "debian",            "kernel": "5.15.49-linuxkit",            "name": "Ubuntu",            "platform": "ubuntu",            "type": "linux",            "version": "20.04.5 LTS (Focal Fossa)"        }    },    "metricset": {        "name": "stubstatus",        "period": 10000    },    "nginx": {        "stubstatus": {            "writing": 1        }    },    "service": {        "address": "http://elastic-package-service-nginx-2:80/server-status",        "type": "nginx"    }}

[aspacca]

hi @aliabbas-elastic , I can confirm that I've observed the following generic behaviour: fields with a range leaning towards the minimum bound of the range

i think that what you are observing is a corner case of the above when rounding integer ranges with a fuzziness applied. basically you reach a point where the "current" integer value reach the minimum bound of the range, 1 in your case. in the next generation cycle, given fuzziness: 0.6 and range.min: 1, the value that can be generated is 1 < x < 1.6 since internally the value are generated as float and than rounded to integer you end up having 1 again, and so on for all the every following generation cycle

the problem can be probably mitigated with a properly chosen mix of range.min and fuzziness:

a = range.min
b = range.min * fuzziness
b > a + 1

I see two options in order to deal with the problem directly in the code:

• we cannot automatically "fix" the 1 < x < 1.6 scenario rounded to 1 without violating fuzziness. we can agree that we want to violate fuzziness for that specific scenario :)
• we could override the defined range.min upfront calculating the higher value that will not end up in the specific scenario. this does not violate the range.min. not sure about ending up violating range.max

in general, without the extreme outcome of ending up generating the same value after a certain number of events, we should investigate the tendency for random numeric values to lean towards 0. i'm not an expert: not sure if it's a limit of the specific go random package or something more generic to randomness on computer, and/or it is a known limit that can be mitigated with proper approach