search

electrified / asus-wmi-sensors

Linux HWMON (lmsensors) sensors driver for various ASUS Ryzen and Threadripper motherboards
GNU General Public License v2.0
252 stars 30 forks source link

ASUS Crosshair VI Hero reboots or locks #75

Closed gnusuari0 closed 1 year ago

gnusuari0 commented 4 years ago

Reading out the sensors constantly with an extension like GNOME Vitals hangs this board. I have it configured to read sensors every 5 seconds. By blacklisting the kernel module asus-wmi-sensors the motherboard stops crashing, of course I lose VRM temperatures, DRAM, SoC and VCore voltages and fan speeds. I've seen this issue in other motherboards with WMI interface. I also suffered the issue of fans getting stuck or turned off, which was corrected with a new version of the UEFI. But this crashing has not been solved. Their code base seems to be broken.

I leave this bug report for reference.

PS: It's remarkable that ASUS switched to a different super I/O chip and removed the WMI interface in 500 chipset series.

KeithMyers commented 4 years ago

It was necessary for ASUS to develop the WMI interface because of their poor decision to use the ITE87 SIO chipset. Nothing more. The headaches that hardware caused was avoided in the X570 hardware.

electrified commented 4 years ago

Hey there, agreed this sounds like a firmware issue.

Are you using a Zen 2 (3xxx) CPU?

gnusuari0 commented 4 years ago

I'm using a Zen CPU (1xxx).

Hey there, agreed this sounds like a firmware issue.

Are you using a Zen 2 (3xxx) CPU?

0lvin commented 2 years ago

@gnusuari0 Do you have access to 'CROSSHAIR VI HERO'?

Could you please share your dmesg? I like to check that ITE87 sensors have conflicts same as NCT6775 sensors in https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=204807.

Also could you please check steps described in https://github.com/zeule/asus-ec-sensors, UEFI dump looks as board has methods required for EC.

Thank you!

gnusuari0 commented 1 year ago

Nope, I no longer have it. The issue was related to the Linux bug affecting Zen and Zen+ to a lesser extent: https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=196683

I ultimately found that enabling Typical Power Idle in the UEFI stopped crashes. But that's a workaround. The real solution lies in the kernel and it hasn't been commited.

@gnusuari0 Do you have access to 'CROSSHAIR VI HERO'?

Could you please share your dmesg? I like to check that ITE87 sensors have conflicts same as NCT6775 sensors in https://bugzilla.kernel.org/show_bug.cgi?id=204807.

Also could you please check steps described in https://github.com/zeule/asus-ec-sensors, UEFI dump looks as board has methods required for EC.

Thank you!