search

elifesciences / UX-features-roadmaps

A test attempt at moving some of the Product team feature definition and prioritisation into GitHub. The aim is to create more detailed feature definitions, provide more transparent prioritisation and more effective "linking" of product design to development tickets (currently in the xPub project board).
0 stars 0 forks source link

Manuscript title extraction updates... #54

Open chris-huggins opened 5 years ago

chris-huggins commented 5 years ago

Problem: If an author updates/replaces their manuscript file, science beam will attempt to extract the title. There is a risk that we overwrite an edited/custom title with an incorrectly extracted title. The current solution is to not replace it when we update/replace a manuscript, if the text in the manuscript title input is different to the extracted title.

Potential improved option (requires testing): We instead show users what has been extracted (including when first uploading a manuscript file) and allow users to opt-in to using the extracted title or not. When replacing a manuscript, if an extracted title is different to the current title we inform users and give them the option to use the new title or stick with current title.

chris-huggins commented 5 years ago

Mockups:

On first extraction - press "use extracted title" to insert text into the the input and discard the message. Press "hide" or discard the message.

image

When a manuscript is replaced, and the extracted title is different to "current" title.

image

Press "Updated title found" to open the modal to choose title. Press "hide" to discard.

image