search

elixir-europe / BioHackathon-projects-2019

This repository is meant for the participants of the BioHackathon hosted in Paris in Nov 2019 to share ideas, create issues, manage projects, publish materials, create code, etc.
MIT License
24 stars 29 forks source link

Team Green is not FAIR #44

Closed egonw closed 4 years ago

egonw commented 4 years ago

I got complaints that, particularly, Team Green is not FAIR. For example, we don't have identifiers for players (ORCID has been suggested) and we don't have ontologies to describe our skills. I mean, seriously, I cannot find anything on BioPortal for "I would kill for the nomination"! :(

rwwh commented 4 years ago

I have an issue with this issue: it looks more like an epic than a story.... Lets split it up:

The first one we can solve each individually using our team document. For GDPR reasons I will not post the link here....

We really have to make sure to become the most FAIR team. FAIR play FTW!

schymane commented 4 years ago

I FAIRified my response ;-) Surely we need a FAIR play prize? (a la "spirit" prize in Ultimate Frisbee?)

DeniseSl22 commented 4 years ago

We could start building the ontology with this resources; tennis is close enough to table tennis right?

rombaum commented 4 years ago

@DeniseSl22 can we merge this skills with table skills & techniques? I think then we will be on a good way.

MarekSuchanek commented 4 years ago

@DeniseSl22 @rombaum Great ideas 👍 🎾 I think that instead of merging, it should be more convenient to run some automatic ontology mapping tool to find an alignment with correspondences between tennis and table-use vocabularies. For example, semantic relations between o1:serve (a table) and o2:serve (a tennis ball) or o1:BreakPoint (point that could result to win) and o2:BreakPoint (point that is the result of the loss, since it is where your table broke).

uniqueg commented 4 years ago

I think the labels "Team Green" and "help wanted" are redundant.

DeniseSl22 commented 4 years ago

Yes, I think this is a perfect example to check how we can align ontologies for different but related disciplines together @rombaum @MarekSuchanek . And we definitely need some help with this, since I'm neither a table nor tennis nor table tennis expert @uniqueg ;) . Who got nominated to take the win on behalf of our team @rwwh ?

rwwh commented 4 years ago

Green will cheer for Vahid Kiani and Jacek Lebioda!

egonw commented 4 years ago

FAIR did not bring is much.