elixir-europe / rdmkit

ELIXIR Data Management Toolkit - Find the answers to your research data management questions here.
https://rdmkit.elixir-europe.org
Other
77 stars 133 forks source link

Update request for Sensitive data page #1136

Closed pinarpink closed 1 year ago

pinarpink commented 1 year ago

This page addresses the topic of detemining and reducing data sensitivity. we can consider renaming the page from "Sensitive data" to "Data sensitivity" to better reflect page content.

This page lists in the tools section to several tools, mostly frameworks and environments to host and process sensitive data. The listing is due to the "sensitive data" markup on tools in the tools tabke. the page text makes to reference to any of the tools. so I'd suggest for each tool

For the following two tools:

pinarpink commented 1 year ago

@rwwh would you approve the renaming of the "Sensitive data" page as "Data sensitivity"?

rwwh commented 1 year ago

I have no fundamental problem with the naming. However note three things:

  1. The page is under "your task" and "data sensitivity" is not the name of a task. This is the same for many other pages in this section: "Data protection" can be a task/responsibility, but "Data management plan" is a thing.
  2. Naming all of the task pages "Data x" and listing them alphabetically under "D" is a bit weird.
  3. Any renaming of pages is accompanied by an appropriate "redirect"?
pinarpink commented 1 year ago
rwwh commented 1 year ago

If it called anything like "Data Classification" the index becomes useless: nobody will look for content about sensitive data under that name, and there are so many other forms of classification that are not sensitivity-related and not mentioned on that page.

I'm not dealing with tools list: this is probably a typical "specialist" vs "compatible" issue. Is your supermarket listed under "eggs" in the yellow pages? Nope. Similarly, we have to decide whether the tag "sensitive data" (as example) should be attached to any tool that can deal with sensitive data (i.e. all those that are not incompatible with it), or only to tools that perform specialized services for sensitive data.

pinarpink commented 1 year ago

Thank you Rob. Let's go for "Data sensitivity". An outcome of the recent hackathon is a feature that allows referring to tools from within text in a manner that the site theme understands; tag-based linking of tools to pages and the automatic tool listings will disappear.

bedroesb commented 1 year ago

@elixir-europe/rdmkit-editors, do we change Sensitive data to Data sensitivity?