search

embeddedt / VintageFix

FerriteCore and ModernFix venturing into the stone age of 1.12
https://legacy.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/vintagefix
Other
66 stars 6 forks source link

VintageFix causing broken textures. #73

Closed whoslinny closed 11 months ago

whoslinny commented 12 months ago

More info here.

xJon commented 12 months ago

Summary for ease of reviewing:

textures are always buggy and broken. This includes all blocks and all items. https://mclo.gs/7H7whZ0 image image

Might be an incompatibility with Intel GPU or drivers.

embeddedt commented 12 months ago

Other textures (such as the buttons in the creative menu) also appear broken, and those shouldn't be directly impacted by VintageFix. I also suspect it's driver-related.

xJon commented 12 months ago

@embeddedt I don't understand why removing VintageFix resolved it though.

embeddedt commented 12 months ago

There are many variables that changes, such as the number of textures that end up on the atlas (since the vanilla algorithm is less greedy), as well as the way they are arranged on the atlas (ViF uses a faster stitching algorithm but it might position things differently). If the exact same mod set doesn't reproduce that behavior on different hardware, it's more likely to be a driver issue than a mod issue (although the latter is still a possibility).

xJon commented 12 months ago

Also I didn't realise what you meant earlier but the buttons for the creative menu (the arrows) have their textures changed by the modpack.

xJon commented 12 months ago

There are many variables that changes, such as the number of textures that end up on the atlas (since the vanilla algorithm is less greedy), as well as the way they are arranged on the atlas (ViF uses a faster stitching algorithm but it might position things differently). If the exact same mod set doesn't reproduce that behavior on different hardware, it's more likely to be a driver issue than a mod issue (although the latter is still a possibility).

So, basically, maybe it's incompatible with some Intel GPUs/drivers? Similarly to Nothirium?

embeddedt commented 12 months ago

That's my theory; at the moment I don't have another explanation for this many textures being white.

embeddedt commented 11 months ago

Sodium usually recommends users of these older Intel CPUs to upgrade to this Intel driver version; you could give it a try, but I don't personally have hardware of that era to test with.

embeddedt commented 11 months ago

I'll close this as I think the issue is hardware-based and not something I can directly fix in VintageFix.