search

emeryberger / CSrankings

A web app for ranking computer science departments according to their research output in selective venues, and for finding active faculty across a wide range of areas.
http://csrankings.org
Other
2.74k stars 3.27k forks source link

consider adding another AI venue #37

Closed emeryberger closed 7 years ago

emeryberger commented 8 years ago

There are currently two, so there is room for one more. Proposed candidates include AAMAS, ICAPS, KR, UAI, SOCS, CP.

brendano commented 8 years ago

UAI is more like machine learning (at least these days? or is it all changing again?)

emeryberger commented 8 years ago

I gathered the numbers for UAI and it is not in the same equivalence class as the other two by selectivity or number of submissions (consistently >30% acceptance rate).

vjmenon commented 7 years ago

AAMAS is quite a big conference and I see that the acceptance rates (as listed here - http://www.adaptivebox.net/CILib/CICON_stat.html) are consistently below 25%.

emeryberger commented 7 years ago

I also consider size (# of submissions) and impact factors. AAMAS and UAI are not in the same equivalence class as IJACI and AAAI -- those conferences are 5x to 6x larger (by # of submissions).

IJCAI '16: 2294 papers submitted, 551 accepted (24%) (see http://www.ijcai.org/Proceedings/16/Papers/001.pdf)

AAAI '17: 2590 submissions, 638 accepted (25%)

AAMAS '16: 411 submissions, 109 accepted (25%) http://www.ifaamas.org/Proceedings/aamas2016/pdfs/welcome.pdf

UAI '16: 275 submissions, 85 accepted (30%) http://auai.org/uai2016/proceedings/uai-2016-proceedings.pdf