search

emmo-repo / EMMO

Elementary Multiperspective Material Ontology (EMMO)
Other
61 stars 16 forks source link

Missleading Class-Subclass hierachy in SIDimensionalUnits #281

Open markdoerr opened 4 months ago

markdoerr commented 4 months ago

MassUnit, TemperatureUnit, LengthUnit, etc. are currently modelled as subclasses of SIDemsinalUnit.

This is not correct, as there exist non-SI MassUnits, LengthUnits, TemperatureUnits ....

Shouldn't the subclasses be better called "MassSIUnit", "TemperatureSIUnit", "LengthSIUnit" ?

jesper-friis commented 4 months ago

Agree, there exist non-SI MassUnits, LengthUnits, TemperatureUnits ....

However, the "SI" in the label of SIDimensionalUnit does not mean that it is the class of dimensional SI units (which we would have called DimensionalSIUnit). Instead it refer to dimensional units who's physical dimensionality is described according to SI.

markdoerr commented 4 months ago

Thanks, @jesper-friis , for the fast explanation. Since this subtle difference, you described above, might not clear / obvious to many scientists, it should be worth an design explanation in the annotation of the SIDimensionalUnit class, e.g. like: All derived subclasses of SIDemensionalIUnit are based on physical dimensionalities as described in the [SI specification](https://www.bipm.org/documents/20126/41483022/SI-Brochure-9-EN.pdf)