emoncms / MyHomeEnergyPlanner

My Home Energy Planner - Open Source home energy assessment software based on emoncms framework + openbem
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
22 stars 27 forks source link

Calculation of cost of walls measures #382

Closed cagabi closed 6 years ago

cagabi commented 6 years ago

Hi, this should be obvious but it is so obvious that I need to ask because I cannot believe it if it is wrong.

Not taking into account EWI, we are calculating the cost of a measure applied to a wall as area x cost per sqm

Shouldn't it be netarea x cost per sqm? Net area is the area minus window area.

It's would be such an obvious big error that I am wondering if there is a reason to do the calculation like this

ghost commented 6 years ago

Hello, It is done that way on purpose - the idea being that the cost of the area where the windows are, which you're not covering with EWI, is roughly equivalent to the costs of the detailing around the windows - beads, trims, cills etc. So you'll be relived to know it's not a mistake and it can stay as it is.

We also add area on this measure - that's because the surveys use the internal dimensions of the house, but EWI is applied to the external surface, and should also run past at floor junctions etc - so the total area will be bigger.

Hope that's clear.

M