emory-libraries / blacklight-catalog

1 stars 2 forks source link

Research possible bug with availability and access #1010

Closed lovinscari closed 2 years ago

lovinscari commented 2 years ago

When researching the actions available with an item deemed Not Available, I found MMS ID - 990017055500302486 as showing Not Available. However, the item also has an electronic version available. I would like to know why the electronic item was not showing as available within the search results as shown below. AvailabilityError.jpeg

The Services Page View shows an electronic option available. OnlineAccess_PizzaandPizza.jpg

If this is a bug, please fix it as part of this ticket. If this is anomaly or an error in cataloging record, please document findings within this ticket so information can be shared with the right individual(s).

bwatson78 commented 2 years ago

We are currently basing our online availability off of two record datafields: tag="856" or tag="AVE". This item's availability record, found below, has neither. Interestingly, it does have a datafield with tag="INT"--is this another field we should test for as well?

https://emory-my.sharepoint.com/:u:/g/personal/bwatso9_emory_edu/EUGnr1YT-nhBvl-2O8RWcu8BIqIH-b2JEkE8n_uZQqaC-g?e=CS6wNc

lisahamlett commented 2 years ago

https://knowledge.exlibrisgroup.com/Alma/Product_Documentation/010Alma_Online_Help_(English)/090Integrations_with_External_Systems/030Resource_Management/100Publishing_to_Primo_and_Primo_Central#The_Format_of_Published_Data

Alma Intellectual Entity ID – Stored in the header of the published record, and used as the base for the record ID in Primo:

<header status="new">
<identifier>urm_publish:21239404420001021</identifier>
</header>
bwatson78 commented 2 years ago

@lovinscari With @lisahamlett providing that research above, that means the "INT" field is just reaffirming that we'd classify this item as physical-only, since the "P" in the only "a" tag available indicates a physical item. Should we try to update this record in Alma, or maybe reach out to ExLibris to help with why this record's not showing as an online resource?

lisahamlett commented 2 years ago

Because it IS a physical item: image

lisahamlett commented 2 years ago

It is a lost book: image

eporter23 commented 2 years ago

As discussed in team meeting, we see that there are two records in Blacklight but they are deducing together on the services page. Search result including the two distinct records: https://search.libraries.emory.edu/?utf8=✓&search_field=keyword&q=Pizza+and+pizza+chefs+in+Japan+a+case+of+culinary+globalization