empowerai / fs-permit-platform

Module for intake of special use applications for Forest Service Application Permits
Other
3 stars 0 forks source link

As a user I need to get the most necessary information to be able to understand the rules around Christmas tree harvest in Mt. Hood. #93

Open sadlerw opened 7 years ago

sadlerw commented 7 years ago

Acceptance Criteria

Definition of Done

Tasks

sadlerw commented 7 years ago

Underneath the large green introductory header, include the following welcoming message "Your Christmas tree permit will allow you to cut a tree on the XX National Forest following the rules and regulations on your permit, you may cut a Christmas on the Forest, except as noted below in PROHIBITED information sections." ADSprinkle

sadlerw commented 7 years ago

Blocked until we get info on which are rules and which are not.

sadlerw commented 7 years ago

https://app.zenhub.com/files/106473503/f8b4c0ca-2ebc-4a90-93b7-558234c40bdb/download

cameronwolf commented 7 years ago

Screenshots of what was updated:

screen shot 2017-11-17 at 5 13 31 pm screen shot 2017-11-17 at 5 14 02 pm screen shot 2017-11-17 at 5 14 25 pm
JaneZC commented 7 years ago

Below are some recommended changes. (Note that I also have the remove places to try and remove hemlock species in here so those can be ignored.)

https://app.zenhub.com/files/106473503/fda7f030-2166-4f11-893a-59da6240d217/download

Shortened Tree Cutting Info and removed After You Cut section https://app.zenhub.com/files/106473503/d4cab4da-1ff2-4121-bdda-a3ab5a789698/download

bryanmcfadden commented 7 years ago

Looks good to me.

MelissaBraxton commented 7 years ago

The addition of a rules section at the top of the page is a significant change to the hierarchy of information. We have evidence that people's key questions are when, where, and how to cut. While helping people understand how to be safe stewards of the forest is also a priority, I'd recommend putting the rules together in their own section, and prioritizing the information that helps people answer the when, where, and how questions at the top.

Placing the rules in their own section would also negate the need for the red "!" throughout the page which is a bit jarring and would also be overwhelming if applied consistently (right now, there are some rules that do not have this indicator, which may confuse users, but applying it in every case would result in a lot of clutter). Also, the size of the "!" stays constant but the headers vary in size, so the "!" looks fine with H2 but overwhelms H4.

The fact that there are things marked as rules that do not appear in the "Which rules you need to know" section is confusing--it implies that the other things marked as rules are rules you don't need to know, or maybe not rules at all.

ASprinkle commented 7 years ago

@sadlerw @MelissaBraxton I agree with Melissa's comments above. Order of information presented on the page should flow per user research and testing (something similar to this order); "When" information first followed by "Where", and "How" Trip Planning, Species Information, Contact Information.
The "content flow" word doc that I shared earlier followed an old format from Sprint 2 - and I apologize to the team for that.