emu-wg / rfc7170bis

Revision to RFC 7170 TEAP
Other
0 stars 5 forks source link

No identities are seen before the server has to choose authentication method #14

Closed alandekok closed 1 year ago

alandekok commented 1 year ago

When using normal EAP, the server sees the EAP Identity before it selects which EAP type is being used.

However, with TEAP, the inner tunnel method (EAP or basic password) has to be chosen by the server before it sees any user identity. This limitation means that it is impossible for the server to divide users into groups, as with:

Perhaps we have to define an Identity-Hint TLV which is sent by the peer as soon as the inner tunnel is established? The server can then use this hint to select which authentication method to use.

alandekok commented 1 year ago

Addressed with Identity-Hint in commit 19ea60411