emuse / qmidiarp

Linux MIDI arpeggiator, sequencer and LFO for ALSA and JACK
GNU General Public License v2.0
24 stars 7 forks source link

SMidiArp Seq LV2 plugin crashes in Ardour and Carla #8

Closed tcrass closed 1 month ago

tcrass commented 3 years ago

In order to verify if https://github.com/emuse/qmidiarp/issues/7 is actually a qtractor or a qmidiarp problem, I tried to insert the sequencer plugin into an Ardour 6.6 MIDI track, but in that case, Ardour just craches completely. I also can't open the plugin in Carla -- when trying to open its GUI, I get a crash notification saying that "carla-bridge-lv2-qt5 closed unexpectedly".

Cheers --

Torsten
emuse commented 3 years ago

Related to #7:

I cannot reproduce the qmidiarp lv2 plugins not working in qtractor with transport.

As to other lv2 hosts:

They do work with jalv.qt5, jalv.gtk and Ardour 5 here, including transport.

As to Ardour, you are probably aware that ardour disapproves non-statically linked (self-contained) plugin GUIs (there is lots of discussion on that topic out there), and unfortunately qmidiarp falls into that category.

I had checked with Carla (2.0) once and it worked, too, but I cannot tell what the current status is.

So there's at least two different issues in your case, one with qtractor and transport and probably others with the suil library and I don't know about carla.

For the transport issue, you may check whether this works when qmidiarp is in standalone mode (qmidiarp app) with the jack transport button checked ?