en-wl / wordlist

SCOWL (and friends).
http://wordlist.aspell.net
Other
394 stars 79 forks source link

"Salvadorian" validates, which is incorrect #396

Open getsnoopy opened 8 months ago

getsnoopy commented 8 months ago

I just noticed that Salvadorian validates as a word, which is incorrect. The demonym/adjectival for El Salvador is Salvadoran (which already seems to be in the worldlist), so the former should be removed.

getsnoopy commented 4 months ago

This isn't a variant problem; "Salvadorian" isn't valid in any dialect of English.

kevina commented 4 months ago

The dictionaries and Wikipedia disagree. In fact oxford (premium, requires subscriptions) doesn't even acknowledge Salvadoran. I agree that Salvadoran is the preferred form though.

getsnoopy commented 4 months ago

That's strange. The official government website and most the style manuals of English-speaking governments (US GPO, EU Interinstitutional) all list Salvadoran as the official adjectival/demonym.

DimitriPapadopoulos commented 3 months ago

In any case, I would keep Salvadoran, perhaps Salvadorean because it appears to be the traditional British spelling. The current Salvadorian does not seem right.

kevina commented 3 months ago

And to add premium.oxforddictionaries.com (formally lexico.com) doesn't even acknowledge Salvadoran as the spelling and prefers Salvadorean and marks Salvadorian as a variant.

For British English it seams Salvadorian is slightly preferred over Salvadorean according to GOV.UK and Google Ngrams.

In all languages I will mark Salvadoran as the preferred spelling and the others as variants, for American I will mark the other two as "acceptable" and for British English as common. Basically:

A B: Salvadoran
AV Bv: Salvadorean
AV Bv: Salvadorian

See the SCOWL Readme for the meaning of the symbols.