search

enactjs / enact

An app development framework built atop React that’s easy to use, performant and customizable.
http://enactjs.com
Apache License 2.0
316 stars 31 forks source link

Default Behaviour of Enact InputField is identifying as a bug by LG Webos QA Team. #3283

Closed javadsalman closed 1 month ago

javadsalman commented 1 month ago

Category

Description

My application can't pass the quality check of the LG Webos QA Team because of the default behavior of Enact InputField. When the input is focused and the cursor is at the beginning of the value text and you press the left arrow on the keyboard spotlight leaves the input and when the cursor is at the end of the value text and you press the right arrow on the keyboard spotlight leaves this time as well. It's the built-in, default behavior of Enact InputField but the QA Team identifies this behavior as a bug and rejects my application. I added two videos below which the QA Team provided.

Environment

Doesn't make a difference

Enact version: 4.7.8

Videos

https://youtu.be/UskSpnxDGSw https://youtu.be/NnGF15uSXg0

MikyungKim commented 1 month ago

Dear @javadsalman, I'm so sorry that your application got rejected by the default behavior of Enact InputField. I'm not sure why QA Team did that but as long as I know, the current behavior is expected behavior. You could see the same behavior from Settings > Support > TV Information > Device Name. Why don't you record the built-in app (Settings) behavior and report that this is the expected behavior? Thank you.

javadsalman commented 1 month ago

Thanks for your consideration @MikyungKim. I informed them at the first attempt but they identified this feature as a bug again. That's why I provided two videos. I already bypassed this feature from the code side but it'd be better if you'd inform the QA team if you have a connection with them. Because I think this feature is useful and mustn't be removed

MikyungKim commented 1 month ago

@javadsalman, I'm sorry that I have no contact information at this point. Would you be able to provide me an e-mail address or anything? And have they mentioned what exactly the QA team expected behavior for this case?

javadsalman commented 1 month ago

@MikyungKim, I can't access our sent feedback right now but I share an email from the QA team that sends results to us below. hyohoon.na@lgepartner.com

javadsalman commented 1 month ago

@MikyungKim They expect the spotlight not to leave input focus by right or left direction keys even if the cursor is at the borderline.

MikyungKim commented 1 month ago

@javadsalman, Sorry for the delayed reply since I was out of office. Let me contact the person you mentioned and get back to you as soon as I get the answer.

MikyungKim commented 1 month ago

Hello @javadsalman, I contacted the QA team and he will see if he can close the issue. I think it could close soon. But the issue related the InputField is P3 issue which is not a blocker for acceptance of your app. He said you need to fix P2 bug. I'm closing this issue since the current behavior is the expecting behavior. Thank you!

javadsalman commented 1 month ago

@MikyungKim Thanks for your assist