Closed leonardocustodio closed 4 months ago
PR Description updated to latest commit (https://github.com/enjin/platform/commit/98a286334ec21328ca2f6b689efb0843cc3b596d)
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review [1-5] | 4, because the PR involves multiple configuration changes across different components including Docker, shell scripts, and PHP configurations. The removal of a complete feature (Log Viewer) and the introduction of a new service (relay watcher) add complexity and require careful review to ensure system stability and functionality. |
๐งช Relevant tests | No |
โก Possible issues | Possible Bug: The removal of log volume bindings in `docker-compose.yml` without corresponding changes in logging configurations might cause issues if the application still attempts to write logs to these directories. |
๐ Security concerns | No |
relevant file | configs/core/start.sh |
suggestion | Consider adding error handling or status checks after running `php artisan platform:relay-watcher` to ensure that the relay watcher starts successfully and to manage any failures gracefully. [important] |
relevant line | php artisan platform:relay-watcher |
relevant file | configs/core/composer.json |
suggestion | Ensure that the version constraints for dependencies like `enjin/platform-core`, `enjin/platform-beam`, etc., are compatible with each other and with the Laravel framework version to avoid dependency conflicts. [important] |
relevant line | "enjin/platform-core": "^1.0", |
relevant file | configs/core/.env |
suggestion | Verify that the new `NETWORK` value `enjin-matrixchain` is correctly configured in all parts of the system that interact with the network settings to prevent connectivity issues. [medium] |
relevant line | NETWORK=enjin-matrixchain |
relevant file | docker-compose.yml |
suggestion | Check if the new `relay` service requires any specific network configurations or volume bindings to function correctly, similar to other services, to ensure it operates as intended within the Docker environment. [medium] |
relevant line | relay: |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Add error handling to the relay watcher startup command___ **Consider adding error handling for the 'php artisan platform:relay-watcher' command toensure that the script handles potential failures gracefully.** [configs/core/start.sh [18]](https://github.com/enjin/platform/pull/40/files#diff-1ab5cfcfc8e032f585b6a70cb59659ea3d92417af421a27973951c09f32d90c4R18-R18) ```diff -php artisan platform:relay-watcher +php artisan platform:relay-watcher || { echo "Failed to start relay watcher"; exit 1; } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding error handling for the 'php artisan platform:relay-watcher' command is crucial for robustness and fault tolerance, especially in production environments. | 8 |
Lock the versions of newly added packages to ensure compatibility___ **It's recommended to lock the versions of the newly added 'enjin' packages to preventpotential compatibility issues with future updates.** [configs/core/composer.json [25-29]](https://github.com/enjin/platform/pull/40/files#diff-2c5e09e742287d6e5c5cae43fa69b3407e1547e04805457041dd39d0c8db1a57R25-R29) ```diff -"enjin/platform-core": "^1.0", -"enjin/platform-beam": "^1.0", -"enjin/platform-fuel-tanks": "^1.0", -"enjin/platform-marketplace": "^1.0", -"enjin/platform-ui": "^1.0", +"enjin/platform-core": "1.0.*", +"enjin/platform-beam": "1.0.*", +"enjin/platform-fuel-tanks": "1.0.*", +"enjin/platform-marketplace": "1.0.*", +"enjin/platform-ui": "1.0.*", ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Locking the versions of the 'enjin' packages can prevent potential compatibility issues with future updates, which is important for maintaining stable dependencies. | 7 | |
Enhancement |
Add a health check to the 'relay' service for better service management___ **Add a health check to the 'relay' service to ensure that the service is running correctlyand to facilitate better management by Docker in case of failures.** [docker-compose.yml [82-93]](https://github.com/enjin/platform/pull/40/files#diff-e45e45baeda1c1e73482975a664062aa56f20c03dd9d64a827aba57775bed0d3R82-R93) ```diff relay: image: enjin/platform:latest build: context: . dockerfile: configs/core/Dockerfile restart: unless-stopped environment: CONTAINER_ROLE: relay depends_on: - ingest extra_hosts: - "host.docker.internal:host-gateway" + healthcheck: + test: ["CMD", "curl", "-f", "http://localhost/health"] + interval: 30s + timeout: 10s + retries: 3 ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding a health check to the 'relay' service in the Docker configuration is a good practice for monitoring service health and ensuring reliability. | 7 |
PR Type
enhancement, configuration changes
Description
.env
file to use a new network identifier, reflecting changes in the network infrastructure.composer.json
and removed the Log Viewer package, streamlining dependencies.Changes walkthrough ๐
log-viewer.php
Remove Log Viewer Configuration
configs/core/config/log-viewer.php
project.
.env
Update Network Environment Variable
configs/core/.env - Changed the NETWORK environment variable to 'enjin-matrixchain'.
config.json
Add Relay Node Configuration
configs/daemon/config.json - Added a new 'relay_node' configuration.
docker-compose.yml
Update Docker Compose Configuration
docker-compose.yml
start.sh
Add Relay Watcher Startup Command
configs/core/start.sh
watcher.
composer.json
Update Composer Dependencies
configs/core/composer.json