Closed leonardocustodio closed 3 weeks ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 2 ๐ต๐ตโชโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Hardcoded Repository The Docker repository name 'platform' is hardcoded in the environment variables. Consider using a variable or secret for flexibility and maintainability. Missing Error Handling The script does not include error handling for Docker commands. It's recommended to add error checks after commands like `docker login`, `docker build`, and `docker push` to ensure the workflow fails gracefully if an error occurs. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Security |
Enhance security by using the
___
**Use the | 9 |
Best practice |
Add error handling to Docker commands to ensure the workflow fails gracefully___ **Add error handling for Docker commands to ensure the workflow fails gracefully andprovides useful error messages if any command fails.** [.github/workflows/push-image-to-dockerhub.yml [26-30]](https://github.com/enjin/platform/pull/52/files#diff-375807204432883d2fe0f02e08e633760f5802823833f872fd5e68d8b0939c6fR26-R30) ```diff run: | + set -e docker login --username $DOCKERHUB_API_USERNAME --password $DOCKERHUB_API_TOKEN docker build -t enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG . docker push enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG docker tag enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest docker push enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding error handling is a best practice that ensures the workflow fails gracefully, providing useful error messages. This improves the robustness and reliability of the workflow. | 8 |
Add a cleanup step to remove local Docker images after pushing to conserve space___ **Consider adding a cleanup step to remove local Docker images after pushing toDockerHub to conserve space on the runner.** [.github/workflows/push-image-to-dockerhub.yml [26-30]](https://github.com/enjin/platform/pull/52/files#diff-375807204432883d2fe0f02e08e633760f5802823833f872fd5e68d8b0939c6fR26-R30) ```diff run: | docker login --username $DOCKERHUB_API_USERNAME --password $DOCKERHUB_API_TOKEN docker build -t enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG . docker push enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG docker tag enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest docker push enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest + docker rmi enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: The cleanup step is a good practice to conserve space on the runner, but it is not critical for the workflow's functionality. It is a minor improvement in terms of resource management. | 6 | |
Maintainability |
Improve flexibility and maintainability by using environment variables for repository and tag names in Docker commands___ **Replace the hardcoded repository and tag names in the Docker commands withenvironment variables to make the workflow more flexible and maintainable.** [.github/workflows/push-image-to-dockerhub.yml [26-30]](https://github.com/enjin/platform/pull/52/files#diff-375807204432883d2fe0f02e08e633760f5802823833f872fd5e68d8b0939c6fR26-R30) ```diff run: | docker login --username $DOCKERHUB_API_USERNAME --password $DOCKERHUB_API_TOKEN - docker build -t enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG . - docker push enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG - docker tag enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest - docker push enjin/$DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest + docker build -t $DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG . + docker push $DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG + docker tag $DOCKER_REPOSITORY:$IMAGE_TAG $DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest + docker push $DOCKER_REPOSITORY:latest ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves maintainability by using environment variables, which makes the workflow more flexible and easier to update. However, the improvement is not critical as the current setup is functional. | 7 |
PR Type
enhancement, configuration changes
Description
docker
topush
, and permissions have been updated to includeid-token: write
andcontents: read
.latest
before being pushed to DockerHub.Changes walkthrough ๐
push-image-to-dockerhub.yml
Simplify and streamline Docker image push workflow
.github/workflows/push-image-to-dockerhub.yml
docker
topush
.Docker images.