enram / vpts-csv

Data exchange format for biological signals detected by weather radars
https://aloftdata.eu/vpts-csv/
MIT License
3 stars 3 forks source link

Field name alternatives #32

Closed peterdesmet closed 2 years ago

peterdesmet commented 2 years ago

I have now added field name alternatives (e.g. HGHT for height) at https://enram.github.io/vpts/format/, so users can recognize previously used names for fields. These are:

@adokter I guess I should not add the following three, as these require a conversion (and are thus not the same):

niconoe commented 2 years ago

Does that mean that the same data can be found under different column names?

I'm not sure how desirable that is (it might be easier to produce files in some cases, but harder to consume them).

If the sole goal is to make the user recognise them, why not require a single column name, but document the alternative names (for example: require the field to be named sd_vpp and add: you might know this data as rmse?

peterdesmet commented 2 years ago

My intent was more to indicate to the user “also known as” and not provide conversion.

However, it is likely we will need conversion at some point, especially if the standard gets a new version and/or we want to convert legacy data.

adokter commented 2 years ago

@adokter I guess I should not add the following three, as these require a conversion (and are thus not the same):

correct

peterdesmet commented 2 years ago

The website well now state the alternative names as Also known as, which I hope makes it clearer that it should not be used as a header.

I have also expanded radar_lat to radar_latitude and radar_lon to radar_longitude, as I see no point in abbreviating those terms. Let me know if that is ok.