About bibliographical references

erc-dharma / tfc-nusantara-epigraphy

DHARMA project task force C, Nusantara epigraphic corpus

https://dharma.hypotheses.org/

Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International

1 stars 0 forks source link

About bibliographical references #19

Closed ajaniak closed 3 years ago

ajaniak commented 4 years ago

Dear @erc-dharma/nusantara-epigraphy,

It seems you haven't really started working on those, but for some of you more advanced in their work, please take the following remarks into account:

the prefix bib: have been forgotten several times for both @source and @target, also it is necessary for the second reference, e.g not bib:Bosch1928_01 Sarkar1971-1972_01 but bib:Bosch1928_01 bib:Sarkar1971-1972_01
some shortTitles are not well formed (2 authors without the +, missing ending number.... ). Be careful with this, any mistake will make impossible retrieving data from Zotero.
@unit="annex haven't been planed by the EG, could @unit="appendix" be enough ?
<citedRange> always take the attribute @unit.

Best,

arlogriffiths commented 4 years ago

Thanks a lot.

I am the source for the erroneous bib:Bosch1928_01 Sarkar1971-1972_01, and have now corrected that mistake in the relevant file.
please indicate which files are concerned by the problem of ill-formed shortTitles
yes, @unit="appendix" is fine: which files are concerned?
which files lack @unit on <citedRange>

ajaniak commented 4 years ago

For @unit:

@aditiagunawan
- Batutulis
- Huludayeuh
- kawali_1a
- kebantenan_1
- kebantenan_2
- Linggawangi.xml
@arlogriffiths
- Wurare
@ekobastiawan
- Gadhakuti
- Maribong
- PakisWetan
@m-schoettel
- Canggu
- Kusmala
- Paguhan

ajaniak commented 4 years ago

@unit="appendix" is only in Canggu

arlogriffiths commented 4 years ago

Sorry, Axelle, EG p. 116 says:

by default, <citedRange> will be understood to refer to page numbers, so references to pages can simply be added as the content of this element use a hyphen to record a range of pages, e.g. <citedRange>12-21</citedRange> the number of the last page should always be recorded in full, e.g. <citedRange>123-124</citedRange> (not 123-4 or 123-24) use a comma (followed by a space) to list non-adjacent pages, e.g. <citedRange>12, 24</citedRange> to refer to an entity other than a page, add the attribute @unit to <citedRange> with one of the following values

So I don't think at least the cases in Wurare.xml are encoding errors.

Or do you think the EG shouild be changed on this point?

ajaniak commented 4 years ago

My mistake.

arlogriffiths commented 3 years ago

@ajaniak : can we close this issue now?