eric-wieser / caius-rooms

The room balloting and information system for gonville and caius college
http://roompicks.caiusjcr.co.uk/
4 stars 1 forks source link

Add ability to see which rooms go the fastest in a ballot #20

Open Pinpickle opened 8 years ago

Pinpickle commented 8 years ago

Firstly, thank you @eric-wieser for making this!

It makes sense to set our sights realistically when choosing houses to pick from for our balloting time. This could be implemented to varying degrees of usefulness/complexity but some way to see how popular a room is based on previous ballots would help us set those sights realistically.

Useful implementations could be to:

I imagine the complexities of this would come from is the numbers around this stem from multiple ballots. e.g. a room may be the half most popular room, not be chosen for one ballot, but then snagged up very quickly in the next (resulting in a popularity that is too high if calculated naively).

eric-wieser commented 8 years ago

I worry that any attempt to do this will be either be self-fulfilling, or self-defeating. People behave differently when they have information about how they should behave

jack-fellows commented 8 years ago

Yes we've looked into this kind of thing before but didn't think it would be that helpful, and more likely to sway people in a potentially arbitrary direction when picking a room. It should be fairly clear the rough order rooms go in (Old Courts / St Mike's / Town / Morti).

eric-wieser commented 8 years ago

This might be sensible to apply at a per-building level, rather than a per-room level

jack-fellows commented 8 years ago

Yes that could be more useful, to give (explicitly) the rough order of the ballot. Would it be wise to select the places used though, as some staircases have very few rooms and so it may be better to pick the parent place (e.g. "Gonville Court") to rank by?