ericmazur / PnPbook

Tracking of typos, errors, and improvements for "The Principles and Practice of Physics"
0 stars 1 forks source link

FBD CM concept ... or not #93

Open JohnDenker opened 9 years ago

JohnDenker commented 9 years ago

In chapter 8 on page 182 in the procedure for drawing free body diagrams:

Procedure item 1 refers to the center of mass.

Suggestion 1: Don't mention CM at all.

Rationale: It seems to me the CM is irrelevant to the physics, because we are assuming one-dimensional motion of a rigid body.


Suggestion 2: Leave the CM symbol out of the force-vector diagram.

Rationale: In the FBD it is unnecessary and often unhelpful to draw the forces as "attached" to the CM or otherwise "attached" to the free body. It is important to remember that a vector has direction and magnitude, but it does not have a position. Therefore we are free to arrange the vectors on the diagram however we find convenient. For example,

           ---------->
           <------<---

See #90 for a catalog of related issues.