search

esotalk / esoTalk

Fat-free forum software.
GNU General Public License v2.0
1.47k stars 237 forks source link

Member group privacy functionality unclear #158

Open simondahla opened 10 years ago

simondahla commented 10 years ago

I checked the Only allow members of this group to see who else is in it

Privacy Option

but if I enter /index.php/members I can still see all members of the forum.

Member List

I need the groups to be totally separated form each other...

tobyzerner commented 10 years ago

The intended behaviour of that checkbox is to prevent members who aren't in the group from listing the group's members (i.e. filtering the member list by that group) — not from seeing them altogether.

Granted, this behaviour's use-case is very niche (it was implemented for Xojo Inc.)

Perhaps an additional checkbox should be implemented with the behaviour you're requesting.